| NNNN BAD DEVELOPERS NNNN | |||||||||||||
|
EXPOSING DEVELOPERS WHO FAIL TO APPRECIATE AND RESPECT COMMUNITY, ENVIRONMENT AND SPIRIT OF THE LAND |
|||||||||||||
(*average date)
Friends of the Earth Australia is a federation of independent local groups working for a socially equitable and environmentally sustainable future. FoE Australia is the national member of FoE International, which is currently active in more than 71 countries. FoEI is the world's largest federation of grassroots environmental groups, with around 5,000 local groups - including the 12 currently working in Australia. There are more than 1,500,000 individual members in the FoEI network.
http://www.foe.org.au
The National Toxics Network (NTN) is a community based network working for pollution reduction, protection of environmental health and environmental justice for all. NTN gives the community a national and international voice on toxic chemical issues. In particular NTN campaigns to ensure our rights to clean water and air are protected. NTN has an active pesticides campaign and fully supports the work of FOE to expose the inadequacies of pesticide monitoring in drinking water catchments in Victoria.
http://www.oztoxics.org/ntn/indexfront.html

Thorpdale water supply Gippsland. Gippsland Water do not test for pesticides.
There is little monitoring of agrochemicals in surface waters in Victoria. Water authorities have the best set of information in Victoria about pesticides in drinking water, but in many cases even this is most likely woefully inadequate. Between 2006 and 2007, Friends of the Earth, through Freedom of Information requests, gained access to some of the records of the State's Water Authorities mainly covering the years 1998-2007, and was surprised at the lack of information supplied by authorities.
Pesticides detected in Victorian domestic water supplies included; 2,4-D, Glyphosate, Hexazinone, Simazine, Chlorpyrifos, Atrazine and the organochlorines Hexachlorobenzene, Pentachlorophenol, Diedrin/Aldrin, Heptachlor, Methoxychlor, Lindane and Endosulphan (Temephos, MCPA, 245TCP, 4,chlorophenoxyacetic acid detected by Barwon Water 2007-08). The most serious incidents appear to be mostly related to use of 2,4-D, which is classified by the IARC (International Agency for Research on Cancer) as a Class 2B carcinogen - possibly carcinogenic to humans. 2,4-D is also known as an endocrine disruptor. Many of the organochlorines had been banned for some time yet residues remain in sediment, which can be mobilised during rainfall. (Most of the pesticides detected are known endocrine disruptors).
Only one pesticide pollution incident was reported above the Australian Drinking Water Health Limit, with sixteen (seventeen after July 08) coming in above the Australian Drinking Water Guideline Limits. The most at risk water supplies, according to the limited FoI information, appear to be the two open aquaduct systems which flow into the Wurdee Boluc Reservoir and into the Stony Creek Reservoirs managed by Barwon Water. These aquaducts are at risk from cropping and grazing pesticides as the aquaducts flow through open farmland, in some places lower than surrounding farmland. The Broken Creek system managed by Goulburn Murray Water, which supplies the communities of Nathatalia and Numurkah also appears to be at some risk as do some communities relying on channel water in northern Victoria. The longest duration pollution incident reported in the past decade occurred in the Moorabool System (Barwon Water) with the herbicide Hexazinone, associated with weed control in pine plantations, leaching at low volumes for almost 3 years. The pesticide was detected 50km downstream.
Many more questions remain about the quality of drinking water in terms of pesticide pollution. In mid 2007 four water authorities (28.6%) were not testing for pesticides at all (that number is now two). Seven water authorities (50%) were testing on average only two currently used pesticides, leaving only three (21.4%) water authorities testing for between 40-72 pesticides. This means that in late 2007, eleven (78.6%)of the fourteen water authorities were testing for less than 2 currently used pesticides. This is most unsatisfactory.
To put this into context, Friends of the Earth estimates that between 200-300 pesticides are used in Melbourne's water supply above Sugarloaf Reservoir which is dominated by vineyards, orchards, berry farms etc. Melbourne Water only test for two currently used pesticides, atrazine and 2,4-D, which represent approximately <1% of pesticides used in the Yarra catchment. The Maffra/Stratford water supply in Gippsland is dominated by irrigated pasture, yet no testing on pesticides is carried out by Gippsland Water. Much of Ballarat's water supply is dominated by potato farms and plantations. The water authority in the Ballarat region Central Highands Water uses Hexazinone in their plantations many of which surround reservoirs, yet does not test for it or many other pesticides widely used by the potato industry. These examples are not uncommon which means that many water supplies may be at risk but no data is available to determine if pesticides are leaching into these water supplies.
The three most commonly used pesticides used in Australia, Glyphosate, Atrazine and Simazine remain under-sampled across Victorian water supplies. 4/14 authorities test for Glyphosate, 5/14 test for Atrazine and 1?/14 test for Simazine, even though Simazine is registered for use across a plethora and land uses. Friends of the Earth estimates that over 200 'commonly used' pesticides in Victoria remain untested by any water authority, whilst approximately only 70 are tested by at least one water authority. This means that the 140 positive pesticide results recorded in this survey are likely to represent a tiny fraction of the total range of pesticides that could be in the water, particularly in times of heavy rainfall after spraying events. It should also be stated that most of the pesticide testing reviewed in this project has been conducted during a ten year 'dry spell' which may well have influenced overall results to a certain extent.
1) Water authorities must undertake detailed catchment surveys to determine which pesticides are being used in what volumes in different parts of their catchments to aid in the design of more effective monitoring programs. Catchment protection should be a priority including multiple barriers to prevent pest and toxic chemicals getting into waterways. Rapid implementation of water protection policies also needs to occur.
2) Water authorities must be transparent and accountable in relation to pesticide monitoring in water supplies. The number of pesticides tested and the frequency of testing needs to be reviewed to ensure the programs are relevant and measuring currently used pesticides. Monitoring data must be available to the public.
3) A list of Restricted Use "Water Supply" pesticides must be determined by the Department of Primary Industries, after public consultation, and circulated to all pesticide users operating within domestic water supply catchments. This could be regarded as an extension of the current 'restricted use' provisions already in operation. If restricted pesticides continue to be detected they should be banned from use in water supply catchments.
4) The pesticide control of use legislation must be amended to require commercial users of pesticides operating in domestic water supplies, to maintain records of pesticide use for an indefinite period. Copies of pesticide records should be made available to water authorities and the DPI.
5) Postive pesticide detections must be followed up with an investigation by water authorities and/or the DPI to determine the source of pesticide contamination. Remedial action must be taken to stop the source of pesticide contamination entering waterways. Postive pesticide results, at any level, mustbe made public by water authorities.
6) Water authorities managing high risk catchments should invest in water treatment facilities which incorporate the use of treatments to remove pesticide residues, such as carbon filters and/or reverse osmosis filtration.

February 2008: Woori Yallock Creek. Strawberry pesticide spraying in Melbourne's water supply. Pesticides used on strawberries and many other agricultural practices are not tested for by Melbourne Water.
During the 1970's and 1980's Friends of the Earth in Melbourne was very active on pesticide issues. Emphasis on pesticide issues within the Friends of the Earth network in the 1990's 'centred' on Tasmania, particularly in regards to the misuse of Atrazine in forest plantations. For a number of years however members of Friends of the Earth Melbourne’s Forest Collective, (The Forest Network 1993-2004) became increasingly concerned about the use of agrochemicals in the plantation forestry industry. Friends of the Earth was concerned that many plantations (particularly pine) were grown in high rainfall areas of Victoria and in areas that may be used for domestic water supplies.
A list of pollution incidents concerning plantations was compiled by FoE highlighting the fact that pollution events had occurred, but these had largely been confined to Tasmania and South Australia. Very little information was available regarding incidents in Victoria and the privatisation of the States plantation base in 1998 (sold to Hancock Victorian Plantations), meant that plantation forestry was exempt from Freedom of Information requests and therefore ‘beyond the public gaze’. It was also evident that plantation forestry was booming throughout the state. What was the impact of the plantation expansion on the state's water supplies?
In early 2002 and 2003 Friends of the Earth sent out Freedom of Information (FoI) requests to the Gippsland EPA and Gippsland Water, requesting information about positive pesticide detections in Gippsland catchments and catchments that supplied residents in the region with drinking water. FoE had long been involved in monitoring logging operations in the privatised Strzelecki Ranges. FoE had also heard rumours of pesticide pollution in the Strzeleckis, but was unsure where these events had been documented.
Limited information came from the FoI requests except for the acknowledgement that the pine herbicide Hexazinone had leached from a Hancock plantation (at Lecki) in 1998 above Australian Drinking Water Guidelines (ADWG) guideline levels and that Simazine had leaked in a pollution incident, outside of a domestic water supply. It was a shock to learn that testing for pesticides was not taking place by Gippsland Water, they were actually relying on information to be sent to them. Was this also the case with all Victorian water authorities?
North East Water had been contacted by FoE in early 2003 concerning the water supplies for Beechworth and Yackandandah. FoE was sent a list of pesticides and other pollutants stating what North East Water was sampling for. The authority was not testing for plantation herbicides even though Yackandandah has a water supply dominated by pine plantations that were being clearfelled and sprayed with herbicides.
Friends of the Earth began mapping the state’s plantation base in 2001, not only as a means of locating plantations, but also as a means of determining which plantations were located in which domestic water supplies. This information was not added to GIS programmes until early 2007 after grants from the Reichstein and Fouress Foundations. For maps see here.
By and large it was found that new bluegum plantations were being grown outside of domestic water supplies. There are notable exceptions to this trend; Midways in the Otways establishing bluegums and replanting pines with bluegums (water supply for SW Victoria), Harris Daishowa '02 in the Rocky River (Orbost water supply), Great Southern Plantations catchments in Gippsland (Meeniyan 06, Boolara 06, Foster Jan 08), Enviroinvest (Stawell Dec 07) and Woolybutt/Rimbunan Hijau Candowie Reservoir (Phillip Island Apr 08). These incursions appeared initially to be minor in comparison to existing pine plantations located in water supplies, particularly those owned by Hancock Victorian Plantations throughout Victoria and Midway Plantations Pty Ltd in the Otways.
In May 2006 Friends of the Earth and the Otways Conservation Council organized a forum at Gellibrand in the Otway Ranges. From FoE’s existing plantation mapping of the region, it became clear that the water supply with the most plantations located in it in Victoria, was probably the Gellibrand River For Otways maps see here.
The Gellibrand River is the main source of water in south west Victoria, providing drinking water to over 50,000 people. The Otway's largest plantation managers, Midway Plantations Pty Ltd, were establishing new hardwood plantations in the region and replanting pine plantations with bluegum. Bluegum expansion raised the scenario of increased spray regimes and aerial spraying of insecticides. The township of Gellibrand also had plantations within one kilometre of its offtake on Lardners Creek. A representative from South West Water also attended the meeting and provided a list of pesticides that South West Water test for. People attending the meeting were more than alarmed to learn that none of the pesticides used in plantations in the Otways were currently being tested for by the water authority.
In the second half of 2006 Friends of the Earth became aware of a pollution incident at a Hancock pine plantation at Korweinguboora, located south of Daylesford. Since 2002, the plantation had been an issue of concern for Friends of the Earth as 1400ha of the plantation surrounds Korweinguboora Reservoir, which is part of Geelong’s water supply. The Geelong water supply is managed by Barwon Water. Incidentally in a meeting held with Barwon Water, earlier in 2006, Barwon Water had stated that pesticides were regarded as a low risk.
Friends of the Earth conducted a Freedom of Information request with Barwon Water asking for details of positive pesticide readings. The response showed that unlike Gippsland Water, Barwon Water had a more rigorous pesticide monitoring system, however the FoI also revealed that not only had the Barwon system been threatened by the herbicide hexazinone which had first been detected in December 2004, but more serious incidents had occurred a few years earlier with the herbicide 2,4-D (2,4-D is registered for use in plantations but is mainly associated with grazing and cropping).
In 2006/7, the Victorian State Government reviewed the existing Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Act, the legislation responsible for pesticide use in Victoria. Two submissions were sent into this review by two water authorities. FoE managed to get a copy of the Gippsland Water submission which contained some serious statements including; “Records are kept for the application of restricted chemical products, but not for the other commonly used products that have environmental or health implications. Gippsland Water has had difficulty in obtaining information on the chemicals used within a catchment area upstream of a water treatment plant and town water supply… Currently there is no common record of chemical products that are likely to be applied in agricultural areas within potable water catchments…”
After more research into the location of domestic water supplies in Victoria, it became evident that plantation forestry was not the major user of pesticides in all Victorian water supply catchments. Agricultural practices in many catchments were the dominant users of pesticides. The best opportunity then to determine whether pesticides were being detected in these water supplies lay with the water authorites. What this meant is that Forest Network, which had evolved into FoE’s Land and Water Collective, would have to broaden its focus to include agricultural practices and its impacts on water quality.
It soon became clear that to get a clearer picture of what was going on where, FoE would have to start writing FoI requests to all of the States water authorities. At this time, 2006, there were also widespread concerns in regards to an EPA investigation into fish kills associated with the herbicide acrolein by Goulburn Murray Water (GMW). Not only was the authority using acrolein to kill aquatic weeds in irrigation channels and drains throughout northern Victoria, but GMW were also using the herbicides 2,4-D, amitrole and glyphosate. see GMW here . The region was also heavily impacted by thousands of hectares of horticultural and irrigated pasture.
Certain towns in northern Victoria are reliant on channels to provide them with drinking water and a report published by GMW in June 2006 (20) revealed that some of these channels had already been recording low levels of Atrazine, Endosulfan and Chlorpyrifos in town supplies. With the use of herbicides in channels for weed control, what was the risk to consumers of the drinking water? Information also came to hand (January 2008) that GMW also 'regularly' use Weedmaster (Glyphosate) in the Waranga Western Channel (WWC) as a means of controlling weeds. WWC is used as a domestic water supply and will soon be supplying Bendigo and Ballarat via a pipeline being built from Colbinabbin. Some the channels already recording low levels of pesticides can feed into, at certain times of the year, into the WWC. Grampians Wimmera Mallee Water have also stated that they use Glyphosate to control weeds in their channel infrastructure. In the past farmers have been documented using triazines (atrazine, simazine) and amitrole to control weeds along channels and drains (21). Grampian Wimmera Mallee Water do not test for these pesticides.

Tatura Water Supply Channel No.3/5. Low levels of Atrazine and Endosulphan have been detected in this channel.
In mid 2007 Friends of the Earth also began taking a closer look at the Yarra River catchment, upstream of the offtake to Sugarloaf Reservoir. Over 9000 hectares of intensive horticulture occurs in this catchment, within 20km of Sugarloaf Reservoir. This makes one source of Melbourne's drinking water (Sugarloaf Reservoir), supplying 1.2 million residents possibly the highest risk catchment in the state in terms of pesticide pollution of drinking water. See here for more details. Information also sourced from the EPA showed almost no information from that authority regarding pesticides used in the Upper Yarra catchment.
An additional FoI was sent to Barwon Water in July 2008, with results being sent back to FoE in September 2008. An additional 27 incidents were detected by Barwon Water during this time period.
In hindsight, all of the FoI requests should have been sent at the same time, this would have provided a more manageable means of standardising the information. However as the process was also a means of discovery, with snippets of information coming to light over the passage of time, a strategic co-ordinated approach to the requests did not occur. The requests were in fact staggered mainly between July 06 and January 08 and in some cases requests had to be followed with other requests after initial information was not properly requested or gained. Ideally the FoI requests should have gone back to 1977 (the start of the FoI act) but this was deemed as unrealistic by many of the water authorities who had in some cases amalgamated and who claimed that they did not have the resources, time or inclination to get access to that information.
The information is weakened further by many water authorities not testing for a suite of the hundreds of pesticides that are registered for use in Victoria. Furthermore, testing regimes may only occur on an annual, half yearly or quarterly basis, potentially meaning that a pesticide may be leaching into a water supply, but is not being picked up by the authorities. From research conducted by FoE as part of this project, it would appear that between 200-300 agricultural pesticides are used within Victorian domestic water supplies. Approximately 70% of these pesticides are not tested for by any Victorian water authority.
"The Australian Water Resources Council initiated the Victorian Water Quality Assesment Program (WQAP) in 1975 as part of its National Water Quality Assessment Program. Subsequent to this, the Victorian Water Quality Monitoring Network (VWQMN) was established to collect water quality data for all major streams and their tributaries in Victoria. From 1975 to 1991, the VWQMN was re-defined through a number of reviews)" (12) These programs were however not set up to monitor pesticides.
In the Yarra catchment Melbourne Metropolitan Board of Works (MMBW) started testing for pesticides in 1977, as the Sugarloaf Reservoir was on the drawing board. Sugarloaf, later built in the early 1980's would pump water from the Yarra River which also was intensively farmed.. "In 1977 the Water Water Supply Planning Branch purchased five automatic samplers of which four were Manning S-4040 automatic samplers and one Manning S-4040T automatic sampler. The S4040T sampler was used at Yering to monitor the effects of farming and intensive cropping and the use of pesticides, soil additives etc" (32). No details of pesticide results were published and none were published in Summary Statistics from the Intensive Water Quality Monitoring Program (1978 to 1983)..
In 1978 a Cluster of birth abnormalities occurred at Yarram in Victoria (1975-76). A Report entitled "Consultative Council on Congenital Abnormalities in the Yarram District. Victorian Government. October 1978" was produced which investigated the link to the birth abnormalities and the use of 2,4,5-T in weed control (blackberry) and pine plantation establishment. It was criticised shortly after its completion for being 'statistically questionable' .
November 1980 was the date of the commissioning of Sugarloaf Reservoir, sourcing drinking water directly from the Yarra River.
In 1982, the EPA published a report looking at pesticide levels in sediment and water in the Yarra River catchment, Werribee and Little River catchments (1). Positive detections for organochlorines were detected at all sites, including seven sites in the Yarra Catchment, including one site on the Yarra River, just downstream of the location of the future Sugarloaf Reservoir. The report proved that low levels of organochlorines were being washed down the Yarra catchment, which in future years would be added to the Melbourne water supply system. The report mainly focused on organochlorines.
In 1982 a further study into Macroinvertebrates of the Yarra River; stated in regards to Wandin Yallock Creek that "pesticides appear to be the most likely toxic influence at this site. TDE, DDE, DDT and Dieldrin have been detected in the sediments at a site 2km downstream of a major market gardening and horticultural area, and DDT and Dieldrin have been found in the sediments of a site in the middle of the market gardening area...TDE, DDE, DDT and Dieldrin have been detected in sediment samples 8km downstream of areas of intensive market gardening and potato growing..." (30)
Another study (31) published in 1983 looked at pesticide transport in three sub catchments of the Upper Yarra Catchment. The pesticides Diedrin, DDT, DDE, Linuron and 2,4,5-T were detected. Pesticides at one location were most frequently detected in flows during vegetable washing operations. Pesticide concentrations were also generally higher in storm flow samples. Pesticide loads transported from catchments were generally between 1.3 and 9.3 mg/ha and between 134 and 228mg/ha in relation to vegetable washing plants. The authors wrote; "The concentrations of Dieldrin and DDT do not appear to present problems for drinking water supply in the Yarra River itself although, on occassions the concentrations detected in flows from cultivated land during storms and operation of vegetable washing plants exceeded health criteria".(31).
It could be argued that if vineyards are included, the current amount of intensively sprayed agriculture in the Upper Yarra Catchment is in 2008, 9000ha+, a 1000% increase on the 870ha intensive cropping figure quoted in the above study, potentially meaning higher pesticide volumes at a catchment level, also potentially meaning higher levels of pesticide loads transported from catchments, depending on the pesticide and site conditions.
In 1985 the Rural Water Commission of Victoria wrote; "A commitment to pesticide and herbicide analyses by the State Water Laboratory (SWL) cannot be justified at present" (2). They added; "Experience obtained in the past suggests that pesticide and herbicide contamination of the water column is unlikely following pollution incidents. Rather, these organic compounds are readily absorbed onto sediments or particulate matter and tend to be concentrated through the food chain. Analyses of sediments and biota are generally preferable in that they represent a time-weighted average of concentrations in the water, whereas grab samples of water only represent instantaneous values."(2)
This appeared to be the state of play until the 1990's.
"The true extent of pesticide exposure through polluted water supplies is not known in Australia, and governments are extremely slow to respond. In 1993, a joint NHMRC/Australian Water Resources Commission working party was still revising pesticide water residue levels, a process begun prior to the 1989 Senate enquiry. Their tardiness to recommend more stringent guidelines may well be due to the implications such changes will have for local water supply authorities. Most are already aware that many rural water supplies are contaminated with pesticides, and the introduction of new guidelines may render many supplies unfit for human consumption. Perhaps this is why the Victorian Government went cool on the issue after an initial report boldly acknowledged that a proportion of Victoria's country towns' water supplies did not neet minimum standards for safe drinking water as set by the World Health Organisation. 'With few exceptions the water quality of urban supplies outside Melbourne with respect to pesticides, herbicides and heavy metals is essentially unknown, as no routine monitoring for these compounds is currently undertaken" (17)
"By 1991, the emphasis had changed and the same government concluded that 'no significant concentrations [of pesticides] have been found'. However, as the report itself indicated, only OC pesticides were tested for ... Moreover because it used National Health Medical Research Council Guideline Values, the report was also able to claim 'no significant concentrations', even though their own results suggested the need for greater scrutiny of raw data, particularly the peaks in contamination that would 'iron out' when averages were calculated. Dieldrin values for tap water averages, for example, were only one third under the WHO Guideline Values, and the possibility of far greater concentrations occurring in particular community water supplies cannot be excluded" (17)
During the 1980's, 1990's research was also conducted into pesticide pollution of the Ovens and King Rivers. Concerns focused on the impacts of the tobacco industry. Organochlorines were detected upstream of the water supply for Wangaratta. (3) (4)
"I kept on making enquiries and found that those drinking water from Boggy Creek and the King River in most cases suffered disease and ill-health. Wangaratta's water supply is drawn from the King and Ovens Rivers, both of which have a catchment along kilometres of farms growing tobacco, hops, grapes and fruit. In many cases the crops are grown to the actual river itself and often steeply sloping to the water. There are also dairy and cattle farms to the north-east which have been quarantined because of high chemical residues. For many years, tests carried out by bodies such as the EPA, State Forests and Lands and the Rural Water Commission have shown fluctuating levels of cyclodienes in the Ovens and King Rivers but the all clear signal has been given time and time again (Shirley Barber, The Mohyu Valley, Victoria. May 1991. (17)
By 1991 the position of the SWL had changed to; "The SWL has only recently acquired the necessary analytical equipment to test for pesticides in town water supplies. This equipment has been used to 'screen' routine samples and build up a data base of information over time. Where is it suspected that pesticides may be present (such as after aerial spraying on forests or crops) the Environment Protection Agency have carried out more extensive tests to investigate the situation. Recent examples of such investigations are at Aireys Inlet and the Ovens River near Myrtleford." (5) "Analyses for the following organochlorine pesticides are being carried out by the SWL to a detection limit of one tenth of the guideline value set by the World Health Organisation in 1984: Chlordane (total isomers), DDT (total isomers), Heptachlor and Hepatachlor Epoxide, Hexachlorobenzene, Methoxychlor, Gamma - HCH (Lindane). Samples have been collected from most raw water supplies to towns throughout the state. At this stage, no significant concentrations have been found." (5).
“The only incident in which concentrations were found exceeding WHO guidelines (detection limits are generally less than 1/10th of the guideline values) was in the Colac Supply in January 1994. Samples from Olangolah Dam and the No 4 Service Basin were found to contain DDT at concentrations twice the WHO guideline of 2ug/L. Samples taken four days later showed negligible concentrations and none after treatment.” (10).
The following statement was published in the Victorian Water Quality Monitoring Network Annual Report 1993; p111 "The 1990 review of the Victorian Water Quality Monitoring Network (Rural Water Corporation 1991) proposed additional and seperate monitoring for rivers and streams, lakes, reservoirs and wetlands, as well as an increase in the type and number of parameters to get utilised ... There are a number of recommendations from the 1990 Review that are still to be implemented in the VWQMN. Listed below are the remaining Review recommendations as well as three recently proposed future directions for the VWQMN, implentation of which depends on whether resources are available... Organochlorine compounds are widely used in pesticides, herbicides & algacides. These substances are potentially toxic to non-target species, not readily broken down in the environment, bioaccumulate and tend to accumulate in sediments. Monitoring of compounds such as Aldrin, Dieldrin, DDE, DDD, Heptachlor, Heptachlor epoxide, Hexachlorobenzene, Lindane, Methoxychlor and Endosulphan provide base information and indicate potential sources of environmental and health problems". (13)
The only pesticide monitoring published by the VWQMN is a small note in Table 6 entitled 'Parametres monitored as part of the Murray Darling Basin Committee Physico-Chem Baseline Monitoring Programme. Additional Parametres Monitored Herbicides/Pesticides. Denotes monthly monitoring in the Murray River at Morgan (SA) only'. (16) This is also backed up by Table 1: Summary of Network Water Quality Sampling in Victoria (18) which shows that out of the following programs; VWQMN, EPA, MDBC, Melbourne Water, Salinity Program and Biological, only the MDBC is listed as monitoring for herbicides/pesticides. And this was based on information collated in Morgan South Australia!
In 1994, the SWL (a business unit of the Rural Water Corporation) and the Melbourne Water Laboratories (a business unit of Melbourne Water Corporation) were merged to form a private company trading under the name of water Ecoscience.After 1996 Water Ecoscience became responsible for data collected by the Victorian Water Quality Monitoring Network. Again pesticides were not included in the monitoring.
"Following the 1996 Review, a discussion paper was produced (Testing the Waters. The 1996 Review of Victorian Water Quality Monitoring. Technical Discussion Paper" (14). Written in the Review; "The State and Commonwealth governments are mainly responsible for statewide water quality monitoring. Statewide requirements are currently funded by two Government agencies - Department of Natural Resources and Environment and the Environment Protection Authority. In addition to this, Melbourne Water and Rural Water Authorities are responsible for the management of public and private diversions...Overall responsibility for water quality influences is assigned through legislation and policies such as State Environment Protection Policies (SEPP's) administered by the EPA and NRE ... Monitoring was reviewed in 1991, with the current program based on that review, although the recommendations have only been partially implemented, mainly due to funding constraints...Recommendations of the previous review have not yet been implemented ... Monitoring of hydrocarbons and biocides in sediments and metals in water and sediments". The final copy of the 1996 Review (dated September 1997) appears to avoid any discussion about pesticide monitoring. (15)
During the early to mid 1990's the Department of Agriculture also started looking more closely at the impacts of pesticides on waterways (7). The Mitchell River was the main focus area, where traces of atrazine, endosulphan and chlorpyrifos were detected in 1993. Testing expanding into the next year into 5 regions of Mornington Peninsula and Gippsland, including possibly the water supply for Thorpdale. No detections were found at Thorpdale but traces of pesticides (Dieldrin and DDT) were found in very close proximity to the main offtake on the Mitchell River, upstream of the intensive horticultural practices associated near Lindenow. Other pesticides detected in a variety of locations included Atrazine, Metribuzin, Linuron, Diuron, Simazine, Endosulphan, Dieldrin, DDT and Methamidophos. (8)
In the mid 1990's researchers were finding pesticide pollution in groundwater, particularly in northern Victoria near Horticultural areas. (21). Research found "low level contaminations by organochlorinated pesticides (total benzene, hexachloride, heptachlor & its epoxide, total chlordane, total endosulphan, dicloran, endrin, dieldrin, lindane, DDT, DDD, DDE & dicofol), organophosphorous pesticides (chlorpyrifos, fenitrothion, dichlorvos, parathion, ethion, diazinon, mevinphos, tetrachlor, fenvinphos and fenchlorvos), s-triazines (atrazine, simazine, hexazinone and prometryne) and amitrole. Groundwater contamination was identified to be at higher levels in the horticultural areas of Ardmona. Surface water reported only minor contamination" (21)
Melbourne Water did produce a UWRAA report in 1996 looking at a range of contaminants found in sediment in the Yarra Catchment. The report mainly looked at substances such as PAH's (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons), however some pesticides were also included. Tests for BHC, Lindane, Heptachlor, Aldrin, Chlorpyrifos, Chlordane, Endosulphan, DDT, Dieldrin, Methoxychlor were carried out. Positive results for some of the pesticides were found mainly well downstream of Melbourne's water supply, however Dichloran, BHC, Lindane, Heptachlor and Heptachlor Epoxide were found in sediments quite a distance upstream from the Sugarloaf Reservoir offtake. Sediment levels for Heptachlor and Heptachlor Epoxide were very high at a sampling location downstream from Reefton, yet it appears that these levels have not been recorded by Melbourne Water testing at Sugarloaf Reservoir.(22)
Melbourne Water also initiated Streamwatch in the mid 1990's to better research toxicants in the Yarra River. However pesticide testing was generally unlikely to be included in this program. "Baseline data plays an important role in assessing the performance of these initiatives and such data sets are being developed for Melbourne by the Melbourne Water Corporation (eg Lewin 1997, Melbourne Water Corporation 1997). The data collected for this study forms part of the Melbourne Water's ongoing stream monitoring program, "Streamwatch" which is an extensive program including monitoring of water quality, biological health, toxicants and litter. Aside from the Streamwatch program, no extensive studies of stream toxicants have previously been undertaken in Melbourne. However, ther have been a number of site specific studies (eg Bagg et al., 1981, Pouliot 1993, Reed 1992) and an earlier study, on heavy metals only, conducted by the Victorian Environment Protection Agency". (33)
This LWRRDC Report (33) looked at sediments at 44 locations across the Port Phillip Bay and Western Port Bay catchments. Five of these sites were located above the offtake to Sugarloaf Reservoir, however individual results tabled in the report were not given in site specific detail, meaning that it is impossible to work out where the positive samples were taken and in what quantities, many of which were located in heavily urbanised areas well downstream of domestic water supply offtakes.. Pesticides found in sediments in the LWRRDC report included; HCB, Dicloran, Total BHC, Lindane, Heptachlor, Aldrin, Chlorpyrifos, Total Chlordane, Heptachlor Epoxide, Total Endosulphan, op-DDE, pp-DDE, op-DDT, pp-DDT, Dieldrin, Endrin, op-DDD, pp-DDD, Methoxychlor. Mean readings included; Dicofol 0.12mg/kg, op-DDT, pp-DDT 0.11mg/kg, Total Endosulfan 0.045mg/kg, Endrin 0.035mg/kg, Diedrin 0.028mg/kg, Methoxychlor 0.025mg/kg, Total Chlordane 0.020mg/kg, Heptachlor Epoxide 0.020mg/kg, Total BHC 0.014mg/kg, Heptachlor 0.013mg/kg, Chlorpyrifos 0.012mg/kg, Dicloran 0.010mg/kg, op-DDE, pp-DDE 0.010mg/kg, HCB 0.007mg/kg, Lindane 0.005mg/kg, Aldrin 0.005mg/kg. Total OC Pesticides 0.24mg/kg. (33)
On a national level interest was also increasing about the issue of monitoring pesticides in water. "Recently the first reports of monitoring pesticides in waterways in this country have been published and the results are of concern". "... It is generally believed to be the case that surface water management is the principle mechanism for river contamination by pesticides" (34)
By the late nineties the Government was also acknowedging that "low level" pollution of groundwater had occurred in Victoria, possibly in domestic supplies(p19); “The herbicide Atrazine has emerged as a significant contaminant of groundwaters in Europe and North America. Despite its limited usage in Victoria some has been found at concentrations less the guideline values, in drainage waters from irrigation areas and also in vulnerable aquifers used for drinking water supply. (9) (p20) Apparently the Government was also stepping up its monitoring of pesticides; "Additional monitoring for other organics is currently being undertaken for the MoU between water authorities and the Minister. These organics include industrial and other contaminants, organochlorine pesticides and 2,4-D..."Since 1997 Water Authorities have been signing memoranda of understanding (MoUs) with the former Minister of Agriculture and Resesources. These include amongst other things, the requirement for non-exempt supplies to meet WHO, 1984 Guidelines by the year 2000". (9)
Furthermore Water Ecoscience, who were contracted by the State Government to test waters for pesticides claimed in 2001: "Most pesticide concentrations were below the detection limit. No incidents in which concentrations exceeded WHO Guidelines occurred during the period July 1999-June 2001.(19)" This statement therefore claims that positive samples had been detected but no elaboration was made in the report about locations of the sources. The levels of detection used by the State Government were also quite high as is explained in the table below;
|
Pesticide
|
Monitoring Level State Government 1999-2001 (19)
|
Guidelines for pesticides in drinking water from NWQMS (1996). Guideline Limit |
Guidelines for pesticides in drinking water from
NWQMS (1996). Health Limit
|
|
2,4-D
|
100ug/L
|
0.1ug/L
|
30ug/L
|
|
Aldrin & Dieldrin
|
0.03ug/L
|
0.01ug/L
|
0.3ug/L
|
|
Chlordane
|
0.3ug/L
|
0.01ug/L
|
1ug/L
|
|
DDT & metabolites
|
1ug/L
|
0.06ug/L
|
20
|
|
Heptachlor (& epoxide)
|
0.1ug/L
|
0.05ug/L
|
0.3ug/L
|
|
Hexachlorobenzene
|
0.01ug/L
|
||
|
Lindane (Gamma HCH)
|
3ug/L
|
0.05ug/L
|
20ug/L
|
|
Methoxychlor
|
30ug/L
|
2ug/L
|
300ug/L
|
A massive leeway appears granted for 2,4-D. Of all the pesticides tested for with the baseline data, only 2,4-D limits were set well above the levels set for future health limits. This means that large amounts of 2,4-D may well have been entering waterways but monitoring levels were set too high to be detected. This is important as a large proportion of many domestic water supplies in Victoria are dominated by cropping and grazing where 2,4-D use is commonplace.
In terms of water authority testing, results from this report indicate that only South Gippsland Water provided access to tests going as far back as 1991. Testing regimes instigated by water authorities largely before 1995 are unknown. The Melbourne Metropolitan Board of Works (MMBW) may have been testing for pesticides, however records accessed via FoI only go back as far as February 1997.
Other water supply authorities were also sampling but these samples were often limited and haphazard. Such sampling certainly did not test for all pesticides used within domestic water supplies and water authorities were under no obligation to inform other State Government Department's if positive samples were detected.
A Freedom of Information request from Department of Human Services (State Government Victoria) (Incorporating; Health, Community Services, Mental Health, Senior Victorians and Housing)
It said;"The Department's Environmental Health Unit has advised that since 1 July 2004, the quality of drinking water in Victoria has been regulated under the Safe Drinking Water Act 2003. The state's water businesses are required under this act to notify the department of any incident where the drinking water they supply to the public presents a risk to public health. There are no recorded notifications of instances of pesticide pollution in drinking water supplies for the period 1 July 2004 to 3 January 2008.
For the period 1 January 1998 to 30 June 2004, there were no formal regulatory arrangements in place regarding reporting of incidents in drinking water supplies."
Please note that Friends of the Earth in this study compiled a list of 140 incidents of pesticides being detected in water supplies in Victoria between 1996-2007. It appears that if pesticides are detected under the Australian Drinking Water Guidelines limits for particular pesticides, the incident doesn't have to be reported to DHS. Prior to 30 June 2004 it appears that DHS didn't have to be consulted at all by water authorities if a pollution incident occurred. It also appears that with the instigation of the Safe Drinking Water Act in 1994, some water authorities deemed that their catchments were of a low risk and stopped testing for pesticides at this time (re: North East Water, East Gippsland Water, Westernport Water). According to East Gippsland Water; The Australian Drinking Water Guidelines (2004) state that “Routine monitoring for pesticides is not required unless potential exists for contamination of water supplies”.
Although pressure from Friends of the Earth has seen North East Water start testing gain in late 2007 and Westernport Water have been reported as recommencing their pesticide testing in May/June 2008.
It should also be pointed out that the European Union has a policy that pesticides should not be detected in drinking water (Drinking Water Directive 98/83/EC). The EU's position is that "The value of 0.1 µg/l is a substitute for zero, not present in water or below the detection limit". Given that position any positive reading would be regarded as a breach to the EU. Given this fact, most of the Health Values for pesticides in Australia are well over the EU limit.
The European Union (EU) has issued the drinking water directive of 1998 that sets a maximum concentration of 0.0001mg/L for individual pesticides or degradation products and 0.0005mg/L for total pesticide residues in drinking water after treatment (Acero et al, 2000, http://europa.eu.int/water/water-drink/98_83en.pdf)*.
Dec 1 2009: Health Warnings Over Riverside Grazing Ignored
(Please note: The number of pesticides given values under the ADWG probably represent approximately one third of pesticides used in Victorian water supply catchments).
| Pesticide | Guideline Value a (mg/L) | Health Value b (mg/L) |
| Acephate | 0.01 | |
| Aldicarb | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Aldrin c (and dieldrin) | 0.00001 | 0.0003 |
| Ametryn | 0.005 | 0.05 |
| Amitrole c | 0.001 | 0.01 |
| Asulam | 0.05 | |
| Atrazine c | 0.0001 | 0.04 |
| Azinphos-methyl | 0.002 | 0.003 |
| Benomyl | 0.1 | |
| Bentazone | 0.03 | |
| Bioresmethrin | 0.1 | |
| Bromacil | 0.01 | 0.3 |
| Bromophos-ethyl | 0.01 | |
| Bromoxynil | 0.03 | |
| Carbaryl | 0.005 | 0.03 |
| Carbendazim | 0.1 | |
| Carbofuran | 0.005 | 0.01 |
| Carbophenothion | 0.0005 | |
| Carboxin | 0.002 | 0.3 |
| Chlordane c | 0.00001 | 0.001 |
| Chlorfenvinphos | 0.005 | |
| Chlorothalonil | 0.0001 | 0.03 |
| Chloroxuron | 0.01 | |
| Chlorpyrifos c | 0.01 | |
| Chlorosulfuron | 0.1 | |
| Clopyralid c | 1 | 1 |
| 2,4-D c | 0.0001 | 0.03 |
| DDT c | 0.00006 | 0.02 |
| Diazinon | 0.001 | 0.003 |
| Dicamba | 0.1 | |
| Dichlobenil | 0.01 | |
| Dichlorvos | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Diclofop-methyl | 0.005 | |
| Dicofol | 0.003 | |
| Dieldrin c (see aldrin) | 0.00001 | 0.0003 |
| Difenzoquat | 0.1 | |
| Dimethoate | 0.05 | |
| Diphenamid | 0.002 | 0.3 |
| Diquat c | 0.0005 | 0.005 |
| Disulfoton | 0.001 | 0.003 |
| Diuron c | 0.03 | |
| DPA (2,2-DPA) | 0.5 | |
| EDB | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Endosulfan c | 0.00005 | 0.03 |
| Endothal | 0.01 | 0.1 |
| EPTC | 0.001 | 0.03 |
| Ethion | 0.003 | |
| Ethoprophos | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Etridiazole | 0.0001 | 0.1 |
| Fenamiphos | 0.0003 | |
| Fenarimol | 0.001 | 0.03 |
| Fenchlorphos | 0.03 | |
| Fenitrothion | 0.01 | |
| Fenoprop | 0.01 | |
| Fensulfothion | 0.01 | 0.01 |
| Fenvalerate | 0.05 | |
| Flamprop-methyl | 0.003 | |
| Fluometuron | 0.05 | |
| Formothion | 0.05 | |
| Fosamine c | 0.03 | |
| Glyphosate | 0.01 | 1 |
| Heptachlor c (including its epoxide) | 0.00005 | 0.0003 |
| Hexaflurate | 0.03 | |
| Hexazinone c | 0.002 | 0.3 |
| Lindane c | 0.00005 | 0.02 |
| Maldison | 0.05 | |
| Methidathion | 0.03 | |
| Methiocarb | 0.005 | 0.005 |
| Methomyl | 0.005 | 0.03 |
| Methoxychlor | 0.0002 | 0.3 |
| Metolachlor | 0.002 | 0.3 |
| Metribuzin | 0.001 | 0.05 |
| Metsulfuron-methyl | 0.03 | |
| Mevinphos | 0.005 | 0.005 |
| Molinate c | 0.0005 | 0.005 |
| Monocrotophos | 0.001 | |
| Napropamide | 0.001 | 1 |
| Nitralin | 0.5 | |
| Norflurazon | 0.002 | 0.05 |
| Oryzalin | 0.3 | |
| Oxamyl | 0.005 | 0.1 |
| Paraquat c | 0.001 | 0.03 |
| Parathion | 0.01 | |
| Parathion methyl | 0.0003 | 0.1 |
| Pebulate | 0.0005 | 0.03 |
| Pendimethalin | 0.3 | |
| Pentachlorophenol | 0.00001 | 0.01 |
| Permethrin | 0.001 | 0.1 |
| Picloram c | 0.3 | |
| Piperonyl butoxide | 0.1 | |
| Pirimicarb | 0.005 | |
| Pirimiphos-ethyl | 0.0005 | |
| Pirimiphos-methyl | 0.05 | |
| Profenofos | 0.0003 | |
| Promecarb | 0.03 | |
| Propachlor | 0.001 | 0.05 |
| Propanil | 0.0001 | 0.5 |
| Propargite | 0.05 | |
| Propazine | 0.0005 | 0.05 |
| Propiconazole c | 0.0001 | 0.1 |
| Propyzamide | 0.002 | 0.3 |
| Pyrazophos | 0.03 | |
| Quintozene | 0.03 | |
| Simazine | 0.0005 | 0.02 |
| Sulprofos | 0.01 | |
| Silvex (see Fenoprop) | ||
| 2,4,5-T | 0.00005 | 0.1 |
| Temephos c | 0.3 | 0.3 |
| Terbacil | 0.01 | 0.03 |
| Terbufos | 0.0005 | 0.0005 |
| Terbutryn | 0.001 | 0.3 |
| Tetrachlorvinphos | 0.002 | 0.1 |
| Thiobencarb | 0.03 | |
| Thiometon | 0.003 | |
| Thiophanate | 0.005 | |
| Thiram | 0.003 | |
| Triadimefon | 0.1 | 0.002 |
| Trichlorfon | 0.005 | |
| Triclopyr c | 0.01 | |
| Trifluralin | 0.0001 | 0.05 |
| Vernolate | 0.0005 | 0.03 |
a - These are generally based on the analytical limit of determination (the level at which the pesticide can be reliably detected using practicable, readily available and validated analytical methods). If a pesticide is detected at or above this value the source should be identified and action taken to prevent further contamination
b - Based on 10% of acceptable daily intake (ADI).
c - These pesticides have either been detected on occasions in Australian drinking water or their likely use would indicate that they may be occasionally be detected.
Note: Routine monitoring for pesticides is not required unless potential exists for contamination of water supplies.(29)
In 2007 the Department of Primary Industries published the "Review of agrochemical contamination of waterways within agricultural areas of Victoria”. In regards to surface water the review said p7; “There has been very little monitoring of agrochemicals in surface waters in Victoria. Organochlorines found in a number of areas, particularly in the Ovens catchment. Atrazine, metribuzin, endosulfan, and chlorpyrifos detected in Gippsland surface waters (concentrations low and below guideline values). Monitoring in the Melbourne metropolitan area has indicated agrochemical contamination from urban sources.” (23)
What can be added to this statement is; Water authorities in Victoria have in recent years detected the following pesticides in surface water in domestic water supplies; 2,4-D, Hexachlorobenzene, Pentachlorophenol, Dieldrin, Glyphosate, Aldrin, Heptachlor, Hexazinone, Methoxychlor, Simazine, Lindane, Chlorpyrifos, Endosulphan and Atrazine. Acrolein has also been detected when used and Bifenthrin, Esfenvalerate & Taufluvalinate have been detected in relatively high levels upstream of a town water supply. (Barwon Water also detected Temephos, MCPA, 245TCP and 4, chlorophenoxyacetic acid between July 2007-July 2008).
The most serious concern appears to be the open aquaduct supply system to both Wurdee Boluc Reservoir and Stony Creek Reservoir managed by Barwon Water (Geelong and district drinking water). Three instances of pesticides (2,4-D & Glyphosate) entering the Wurdee Boluc system have been detected in the past 4 years (An additional 15 instances were detected in the Wurdee Boluc System between July 2007-July 2008). One incident possibly lasting for some time (3 months), with 2,4-D readings in May 2003 breaching the ADWG health value, however this was not widely known because it occurred before July 1 2004, when such an incident would have to have been reported under the Safe Drinking Water Act. See here for more information about Geelong's water supplies.

Wurdee Boluc Aquaduct can be impacted by farm run-off at several location where the water level is below the upslope.
High readings of 2,4-D were also recorded by Barwon Water in August 2003 at Wurdee Boluc and Stony Creek Reservoir #3. The May Wurdee Boluc 2,4-D Incident, remains the only example of pesticide levels breaching the ADWG health value anywhere in the state over the 1998-2007 period. The Stony Creek Reservoir incident also recorded relatively high levels of 2,4-D in August 2003, 66% of ADWG health value and 200 times higher than the ADWG guideline value.(2,4-D was also detected in the Moorabool system June 2008). It is clear that agricultural practices, cropping, in close proximity to the aquaducts are the culprits for this pollution. Was an audit of cropping located nearby the aquaducts conducted by Barwon Water and why did three seperate incidents occur within a 3 month time frame with the same pesticide?

Bolwarrah Aquaduct, part of Geelong and district water supply.
2,4-D runoff and use in the Broken Creek catchment in the north of the state is also of concern, with a reading 170 times higher than the guideline value occurring in June 2005 at Numurkah.
The longest recorded residues of pesticides have been recorded again by Barwon Water with hexazinone leaching into Geelong’s water supply (at low levels) for almost 3 years (4 years after getting access to Barwon Water data in September 2008). The hexazinone was found to be leaching from a plantations managed by Hancock Victorian Plantations, with some hexazinone residues detected 50km offsite. Only one water authority, Barwon Water, tests for hexazinone (North East Water began testing again in 2008). If this incident were to happen (or has happened) elsewhere in Victoria noone would be the wiser, which is quite surprising considering the high leaching and long residual effect of hexazinone.

1400 ha of pine plantations surround Korweinguboora Reservoir in Geelong's water supply. Hexazinone has been leaching from this site since December 2004.
Also of concern is the detection of Atrazine, Glyphosate and Endosulfan in channels managed by Goulburn Murray Water. Low levels of Atrazine and Endosulphan were detected each year over a 3 year period in a project under the control of Goulburn Murray Water.(20) What was alarming was that although these detections were considered to be low, none were detected by Goulburn Valley Water, Coliban Water or Lower Murray Water, the authorities responsible for providing drinking water. High levels of Glyphosate were also found to be found in Broken Creek and Lake Nagambie after weed control activities carried out by Goulburn Murray Water (24). Once again though, the events were not picked up by Goulburn Valley Water monitoring indicating that pesticide 'spikes' can get through the monitoring system undetected. (It should also be noted that Goulburn Murray Water recorded 16 positive readings for Endosulfan (4) and Atrazine (12) at the Lake Nagambie/Kirwans Bridge sample point during the same study. The township of Nagambie draws water from the Nagambie Lakes. If these pesticides were detected at Kirwans Bridge there is also a possibility that they may also have been present in the Nagambie supply. Total concentrated endosulfan between October to December 2005 was the highest anywhere in Goulburn Murray Water's 6 irrigation areas. Interestingly this same water body is now the water supply for the cities of Bendigo and Ballarat since the opening of the Goldfields Pipeline in 2008. Water for Ballarat and Bendigo is extracted from the Waranga Western Channel at Colbinabbin. This water in turn is sourced from the Warange Basin after being diverted by the Stuart Murray and Cattanach Canals at Goulburn Weir).
Broken Creek about 6km upstream from Nathalia. Glyphosate is used to kill aquatic weeds in this water supply and was recorded at high levels in 2005 above Nathalia. 2,4-D, well above guideline limits for drinking water was detected in Broken Creek at Numurkah in June 2005. Pentachlorphenol detected at Numurkah also in 2005.
The much publicised triazines Simazine and Atrazine were recorded in 4 instances by water authorities and 33 times in water supplies by a study by Goulburn Murray Water. Simazine was recorded at Rocky River (Orbost water supply) leaching from a bluegum plantation in August 2002 and atrazine was found in May 2006 at three locations on the Murray River by Lower Murray Water. The Atrazine readings at three locations in the Murray River (0.03µg/L), with lower levels detected by GMW in channels supplying towns Katatamatite, Kerang, Tatura, Rochester/Corop, West Boort?. The Simazine levels (0.2µg/L) in Rocky River catchment are also of concern and were detected by the company Harris Daishowa. These levels were a long way under the ADWG levels for Atrazine (40µg/L) & Simazine (20µg/L), however it would be erroneous to assume that because low levels of pesticides are detected that they are not having an impact. Levels of atrazine and simazine as low as 0.1 µg/L have been found to chemically castrate amphibians. See this website for further details.
"A number of organochlorine chemicals called persistent organic pollutants (POPs) were detected in Victoria’s water supplies. Although no longer used in Australia, most were applied extensively in agriculture from the 1950s to the 1990s when they were deregistered. These include the grain fungicide, hexachlorobenzene as well as insecticides like heptachlor, dieldrin and aldrin. Pentachlorophenol, a disinfectant, also used to treat wood was also detected. These POPs are very persistent in the environment partitioning to soil and sediment, as well as traveling vast distances via air and water currents. POPs are toxic and can cause cancer and other adverse health effects. They bioaccumulate in living things and are found in the blood and breastmilk of humans and wildlife. " Mariann Lloyd-Smith (National Toxics Network)
Again Barwon Water recorded a reading 3 times over the guideline limit for Dieldrin in October 1999. Melbourne Water’s Kallista supply also suffered from organochlorine problems in 2000, when traces of aldrin, heptachlor and lindane were found at St John Hill Reservoir Kallista. This reservoir sources its water from Silvan Dam, and little light has been shed on how these pesticides ended up being recorded at St John Hill. Heptachlor was also found at Katamatite by Goulburn Valley Water and high livels of Hepatchlor were detected in Yarra River sediments in the mid 1990's.

St John Hill Reservoir Kallista
Far from providing a detailed analysis of pollution of domestic water supplies, the information does allow analysis of risk areas. Because standardised pesticide monitoring is not required throughout Victoria, these results only give a broad picture of the situation. It is likely that other pesticides would be detected if testing was standardised. For instance Gippsland Water does no testing, yet some communities in the region lie downstream of irrigated farming and forestry land use.
The analysis also only touches on treatment techniques used to 'filter out' pesticides. It is Friends of the Earth’s assumption that these pesticides should not be leaching into waterways at all. To rely on the use of ‘filters’ is a high risk strategy particularly in small communities where sophisticated forms of treatment may not exist. For the sake of brevity, the discussion of filter/treatments only looks at communities which have been subject to pesticide pollution.
| Authority | Amount of Pesticides Tested For | How Often Tests are Conducted |
| Barwon Water | 72 pesticides*. | *Depending on location, 72 pesticides get tested for annually in all town supplies. 47-66 pesticides tested quarterly in town supplies. |
| Goulburn Valley Water | 42 pesticides | Quarterly |
| North East Water | 42 pesticides *+1? | Started testing again January 2008, after not testing since 2004. (*Hexazinone late 07). |
| Wannon Water | 40 + 1?* pesticides | Quarterly (*Simazine supposedly been tested for since November 06?) |
| South Gippsland Water | 12 pesticides | Annual |
| Lower Murray Water | Organochlorines + 5 pesticides | Annual |
| Central Highlands Water | 11 pesticides | Annual |
| Western Water | Organochlorines + 2 pesticides | Annual |
| Melbourne Water* | 9 pesticides | Twice per year (Melbourne Water tests water before providing water to Yarra Valley Water, South East Water, City West Water |
| Grampians and Wimmera Mallee Water | 8 pesticides | Varies |
| Coliban Water | 7 pesticides | Annual tests raw water, quarterly tap water |
| Westernport Water | 0 | |
| East Gippsland Water | 0 | |
| Gippsland Water | 0 |
|
Authority
|
Organochlorines
|
Organophosphorus
|
Other
|
|
Barwon Water
|
21
|
19
|
32
|
|
Goulburn Valley Water
|
21
|
19
|
2 (2,4-D, Glyphosate)
|
|
North East Water
|
21
|
18
|
3 ( Since Jan 08: 2,4-D, Atrazine, Glyphosate)
+1 Hexazinone
|
|
Wannon Water
|
20
|
19
|
1 +1? (clopyralid, simazine?) Wannon
Water remains the only water authority testing for Simazine and this occurred
only once in late 2006)
|
|
South Gippsland Water
|
11
|
0
|
1 (2,4-D)
|
|
Lower Murray Water
|
Yes
|
2
|
3 (Since 06: Diuron, Atrazine, Methomyl)
|
|
Central Highlands Water
|
9
|
0
|
2 (2,4-D, Atrazine)
|
|
Western Water
|
9
|
0
|
2 (2,4-D, Atrazine)
|
|
Melbourne Water
|
7
|
0
|
2 (2,4-D. Atrazine since 06)
|
|
Grampians and Wimmera Mallee Water
|
8
|
0
|
0
|
|
Coliban Water
|
5
|
0
|
2 (2,4-D, *)
|
|
Westernport Water
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
|
East Gippsland Water
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
|
Gippsland Water
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
| Goulburn Murray Water | 96* | Test for Acrolein, Glyphosate, 2,4-D, Amitrole. Have Tested for variety of pesticides depending on study. |
| Southern Rural Water | 1 | Test for Acrolein when used. |
| Goulburn Murray Water | 86* | (See “Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Study Report] June 2006.”) (Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 1/10/06”) *Includes averages over month period. Interestingly none of these positive results were detected by Goulburn Valley Water/Coliban Water or Lower Murray Water. 16 positve detections were recorded at Goulburn Weir/Lake Nagambie. |
| Barwon Water | 77 | +1 detection Colac Water Board 1994 & 27 positive results between July 07-July 08 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | 8+1 | (incl a detection of unidentified peaks 25/8/98 at Mooroopna) |
| Melbourne Water | 3 | |
| Lower Murray Water | 3 | |
| Western Water | 2 | |
| South Gippsland Water | 1 | |
| East Gippsland Water | 1 | Detected by Harris Daishowa |
| Barwon Water | 9 | 1 detection Colac Water Board 1994. One detection above ADWG between July 2007-July 2008. |
| Goulburn Valley Water | 3+1* | also detected unidentified peaks 25/8/98 Mooroopna |
| Goulburn Murray Water | 2 | Glyphosate Weed Control in Broken Creek 2006 |
| Melbourne Water | 1 | |
| South Gippsland Water | 1 |
| Barwon Water | 1 | 2,4-D at Wurdee Boluc, 2003 |
| Hexazinone | 55 | All relate to Korweinguboora pine plantation managed by Hancock Victorian Plantations (2004-7). 12 incidents reported between July 2007-July 2008. |
| Atrazine | 50 | Based on research conducted by Goulburn Murray Water (2004-6), including averages based on monthly results. |
| Endosulfan | 27 | Based on research conducted by Goulburn Murray Water (2004-6), including averages based on monthly results. |
| 2,4-D | 9 | |
| Temephos | 9 | Barwon Water Dec 07 |
| Hexachlorobenzene | 4 | |
| Glyphosate | 3 | |
| MCPA | 3 | Barwon Water Sep 07 |
| Pentachlorophenol | 2 | |
| Heptachlor | 2 | |
| 4, chlorophenoxyacetic acid | 2 | Barwon Water Sep 07 |
| Simazine | 1 | |
| Lindane | 1 | |
| Chlorpyrifos | 1 | Based on research conducted by Goulburn Murray Water (2004-6), including averages based on monthly results. |
| DDT* | 1 | Colac 1994 |
| Bifenthrin | 1 | Based on research conducted by Goulburn Murray Water (2004-6), including averages based on monthly results. |
| Esfenvalerate | 1 | Based on research conducted by Goulburn Murray Water (2004-6), including averages based on monthly results. |
| Taufluvalinate | 1 |
Based on research conducted by Goulburn
Murray Water (2004-6), including averages based on monthly results.
|
| ? | 1 | Unidentified Peaks 1998 Mooroopna |
| Methoxychlor | 1 | |
| Dieldrin | 1 | |
| Aldrin | 1 | |
| 2,4,5-TCP | 1 | Barwon Water Sep07 |
| 2,4-D | 7 | incl Barwon Water June 08 |
| Glyphosate | 3 | |
| Pentachlorophenol | 2 | |
| Dieldrin | 1 | |
| Aldrin | 1 | |
| Hexazinone | 1 | |
| Methoxychlor | 1 | |
| DDT | 1 | Colac 1994 |
| Hexachlorobenzene? | (4) | No ADWG guideline set for this pesticide |
| Bifenthrin? | (1) | No ADWG guideline set for this pesticide |
| Esfenvalerate? | (1) | No ADWG guideline set for this pesticide |
| Taufluvalinate? | (1) | No ADWG guideline set for this pesticide |
| ? | (1) | Unidentified peaks 1998 Mooroopna |
| 2,4-D | 1 | |
| Hexachlorobenzene? | (4) | No ADWG guideline |
| Bifenthrin/Esfenvalerate? | (1) | No ADWG guidelines |
| Taufluvalinate? | (1) | No ADWG guideline |
| ? | (1) | Unidentified peaks 1998 Mooroopna |
| 2,4-D | Wurdee Boluc Reservoir | 12/5/03 |
| 1. | 12/5/03 | Barwon Water | Wurdee Boluc Raw Water | 2,4-D | 34µg/L |
| 2. | 19/8/03 | Barwon Water | Wurdee Boluc Inlet Channel at Wurdee Boluc | 2,4-D | 27µg/L |
| 3. | 5/8/03 | Barwon Water | Stony Creek Reservoir #3 | 2,4-D | 20µg/L |
| 4. | 5/10/05 | Goulburn Valley Water | Sunday Creek Reserve | Pentachlorophenol | 2µg/L |
| 5. | 22/6/05 | Goulburn Valley Water | Broken Creek at Numurkah offtake | 2,4-D | 17µg/L |
| 6. | 21/12/05 | Goulburn Valley Water | Broken Creek at Numurkah offtake | Pentachlorophenol | 1µg/L |
| 7. | Jan 94 | Colac Water Board | Colac Water Supply at Olangolah Dam & No. 4 Service Basin | DDT | 2µg/L |
| 8. | 4/6/08 | Barwon Water | Moorabool WTP Combined | 2,4-D | 1.9ug/L |
| 9. | 8/5/06 | Goulburn Murray Water | Broken Creek u/s Thomson Rd | Glyphosate | 160µg/L |
| 10. | 7/3/06 | South Gippsland Water | Dumbalk - Tarwin River | Methoxychlor | 2ug/L |
| 11. | 8/5/06 | Goulburn Murray Water | Broken Creek u/s Thomson Rd | Glyphosate | 85µg/L |
| 12. | 17/7/07 | Barwon Water | Inlet Channel Salt Creek Lane | Glyphosate | 80µg/L |
| 13. | 4/3/05 | Barwon Water | Korweinguboora Reservoir Hancock Plantation | Hexazinone | 9.4µg/L |
| 14. | 28/10/99 | Barwon Water | Highton Basin Pre Disinfection | Dieldrin | 0.03µg/L |
| 15. | 7/2/00 | Melbourne Water | Johns Hill Plant (Kallista) | Aldrin | 0.02µg/L |
| 16. | 28/3/07 | Barwon Water | Airey's Inlet - Painkalac Creek | 2,4-D | 0.2µg/L |
| 17. | 14/3/07 | Barwon Water | Gellibrand - Lardners Creek | 2,4-D | 0.2µg/L |
| Barwon Water | Wurdee Boluc/Inlet Channel | 3 | 70% of water for Geelong, Bellarine Peninsula & Surf Coast. |
| Barwon Water | Moorabool System/Stony Creek | 3 | Anakie, Staughton Vale, Bannockburn, Gheringhap, Teesdale, Shelford, Inverleigh & Geelong. |
| Goulburn Valley Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Broken Creek | 4 | Nathalia/Numurkah |
| Barwon Water | Highton Disinfection | 1 | Geelong |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Sunday Creek Reservoir | 1 | Broadford etc |
| Barwon Water | Lardners Creek | 1 | Gellibrand |
| Barwon Water | Painkalac Creek | 1 | Airey's Inlet |
| South Gippsland Water | Tarwin River | 1 | Dumbalk |
| Melbourne Water | John's Hill Plant | 1 | Kallista |
| Barwon Water | Moorabool System | 56 |
| Coliban Water/Goulburn Murray Water | West Boort (Channel 5 Waranga Western Channel) (See “Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Study Report] June 2006.”) (Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 1/10/06”) *Includes averages over month period. None of the positive GMW results were deteted by Coliban Water | 22 |
| Coliban Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Rochester - Rochester Channel 1 Waranga Western Channel) (See “Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Study Report] June 2006.”) (Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 1/10/06”) *Includes averages over month period. None of the positive GMW results were detected by Coliban Water | 18 |
| Lower Murray Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Kerang - Channel 14/2 (See “Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Study Report] June 2006.”) (Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 1/10/06”) *Includes averages over month period. None of the positive GMW results were detected by Lower Murray Water | 11 |
| Goulburn Valley Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Katamatite - Channel 7/3 (See “Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Study Report] June 2006.”) (Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 1/10/06”) *Includes averages over month period. None of the positive GMW results were detected by Goulburn Valley Water | 10 |
| Goulburn Valley Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Tatura - Channel 3/5 (See “Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Study Report] June 2006.”) (Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 1/10/06”) *Includes averages over month period. None of the positive GMW results were detected by Goulburn Valley Water | 8 |
| Barwon Water | Wurdee Boluc System | 15 |
| Melbourne Water | St John's Hill Plant (Kallista) | 3 |
| Goulburn Valley Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Broken Creek Nathalia | 2 |
| Goulburn Valley Water/Goulburn Murray Water | Broken Creek Numurkah | 2 |
| Western Water | Glenfern Park Basin + Kerrie Res Romsey | 2 |
| Barwon Water/Colac Water Board | Olangolah Dam Colac | 1 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Violet Town | 1 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Picola | 1 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Katunga | 1 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Sunday Creek Reservoir (Broadford, Heathcote Junction, Kilmore, Wandong) | 1 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Goulburn River offtake Mooroopna | 1 |
| Goulburn Valley Water | Goulburn River offtake Shepparton | 1 |
| Barwon Water | Highton Disinfection Geelong | 1 |
| Barwon Water | Lardners Creek Gellibrand | 1 |
| Barwon Water | Painkalac Creek Aireys Inlet | 1 |
| South Gippsland Water | Tarwin River Dumbalk | 1 |
| East Gippsland Water | Rocky River Orbost | 1 |
| Lower Murray Water | Red Cliffs | 1 |
| Lower Murray Water | Piangil | 1 |
| Lower Murray Water | Mildura | 1 |
| Barwon Water | Barham System (Apollo Bay) | 3 |
| Barwon Water | Lorne | 1 |
| 1994 | 1 |
| 1998 | 1* |
| 1999 | 1 (1) |
| 2000 | 7 (1) |
| 2001 | 0 |
| 2002 | 1 |
| 2003 | 3 (3) |
| 2004 | 14 |
| 2005 | 75 (4) |
| 2006 | 44 (3) |
| 2007 | 33 (3) |
| 2008 | 3 (1) |
|
Water Authority
|
Dates Spanning Information On Pesticide FoI's
|
|
Barwon Water
|
28/10/99 to 1/7/08
|
|
Central Highlands Water
|
23/8/06 to 29/10/07
|
|
Coliban Water
|
2/8/04 to 6/11/07
|
|
East Gippsland Water
|
1995 to 28/12/07
|
|
Gippsland Water
|
10/8/98 to 22/7/06
|
|
Goulburn Murray Water
|
1996 to 1/10/07
|
|
Goulburn Valley Water
|
1/1/96 to 1/12/06
|
|
Grampians & Wimmera Mallee Water
|
1/7/05-25/6/07
|
|
Lower Murray Water
|
1995 to 21/12/07
|
|
Melbourne Water
|
4/2/97 to 2/2/07
|
|
North East Water
|
1/1/02 to 11/11/07
|
|
South Gippsland Water
|
12/3/03 to 23/8/07
|
|
Southern Rural Water
|
11/2/98 to 11/11/06
|
|
Wannon Water
|
4/8/04 to 1/6/07
|
|
Western Water
|
1/11/01 to 15/2/07
|
|
Westernport Water
|
25/1/91 to 3/9/07
|
* means no testing *means dates included under FoI
Results from FOI's show a 37% return based on pesticide monitoring by all authorities since 1991. This means 63% of information pertaining to pesticides in drinking water since that time could not be determined in this project. This figure does not include the range of pestides not tested for by authorities, indicating that existing testing may well be 'stabbing in the dark' in regards to the true extent of pesticide contamination of drinking water in Victoria..
| Authority | 91 | 92 | 93 | 94 | 95 | 96 | 97 | 98 | 99 | 00 | 01 | 02 | 03 | 04 | 05 | 06 | 07 |
| Barwon Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * +to June 08 | ||||||||
| Central Highlands Water | * | * | |||||||||||||||
| Coliban Water | * | * | * | * | |||||||||||||
| East Gippsland Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | ||||
| Gippsland Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | ||||||||
| Goulburn Murray Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | |||||
| Goulburn Valley Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | ||||||
| Grampians & Wimmera Mallee Water | * | * | * | ||||||||||||||
| Lower Murray Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | ||||
| Melbourne Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | |||||||
| North East Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | |||||||||||
| South Gippsland Water | * | * | * | * | * | ||||||||||||
| Southern Rural Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | ||||||||
| Wannon Water | * | * | * | * | |||||||||||||
| Western Water | * | * | * | * | * | ||||||||||||
| Westernport Water | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * | * |
Update: Cattle Insect Repellent DEET (N, N-diethyltoluamide) detected November 2002 0.0207µg/L Newry Creek - upstream drinking water offtake Maffra/Stratford). Results published July 2008 here. No ADWG limits for DEET.
Added Barwon Water FoI (August 2008) 23 positive samples (one above ADWG)
Added Lower Murray Water (May 09 from 07/08 Annual Report) 3 positive samples.
Added Western Water (2007/8 Raw Water Water Quality Reports) 3 positive samples.
Added Barwon Water FoI (August 2009) 1 positive sample.
Added Barwon Water FoI (August 2010) 17 positive samples
Added (December 2009) Goulburn Murray Water (2004-6) 16 positive samples from Goulburn Weir/Lake Nagambie
*This list is based roughly on the most serious incidents being at the top of the list, based on comparisions with ADWG Guideline Values. No ADWG Guideline Values for Hexachlorobenzene, so WHO Guideline used. No ADWG or WHO guideline values for Bifenthrin, Esfenvalerate or Taufluvalinate which are listed at the bottom of list and require further clarification. Positive readings for Acrolein used for weed control in irrigation channels by Goulburn Murray Water and Southern Rural Water not included in table.
Above ADWG Health Limit
1. 12/5//03 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Raw Water 2,4-D 34ug/l (1.13xADWGHealth)
Mostly Above ADWG Limit
2. 19/8/03 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Inlet Chan 2,4-D 27ug/l (90%adwgh)
3. 5/8/03 Barwon Water Stony Creek Res #3 2,4-D 20ug/l (66.67%adwgh)
4. 22/6/06 Goulburn Valley Water Broken Creek Numurkah 2,4-D 17ug/l (56.67%adwgh)
5. 5/10/05 Goulburn Valley WaterSunday Creek Res Pentachlorophenol 2ug/L (20%adwgh)
6. 28/10/99 Barwon Water Highton PreDisinfection Dieldrin 0.03ug/l (10%adwgh)
7. 21/12/05 Goulburn Valley Water Broken Creek Numurkah Pentachlorophenol 1ug/L (10%adwgh)
8. Jan 94 Colac Water Board Olangolah DDT 2ug/l (10%adwgh)
9. 7/2/00 Melbourne Water Johns Hill Plant Aldrin 0.02ug/L (6.667%adwgh)
10. 18/10/00 Goulburn Valley Water Katamatite Heptachlor 0.02ug/L (6.667%adwgh)
11. 4/6/08 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP 2,4-D 1.9ug/L (6.33%adwgh)
12. 7/2/00 Melbourne Water Kallista Heptachlor 0.013ug/l (4.33%adwgh)
13. 2007/8 WQR Western Water Djerriwarrh Reservoir (Raw) Aldrin 0.01ug/l (3.333%adwgh)
14. 4/3/05 Barwon Water Koweinguboora Reservoir Hexazinone 9.4ug/L (3.13%adwgh)
15. 8/5/06 Gouburn Murray Water Broken Creek Glyphosate 160ug/l (1.6%adwgh)
16. 2007/8 WQR Western Water Kerrie Reservoir (Raw) Chlordane 0.01ug/L (1%adwgh)
17. Jan 06 Goulburn Valley Water Katamatite Chlorpyrifos 0.089ug/L (0.89%adwgh)
18. 8/5/06 Goulburn Murray Water Broken Creek Glyphosate 85ug/l (0.85%adwgh)
19. 17/7/07 Barwon Water Inlet Channel Salt Creek Lane Glyphosate 80ug/l (0.80%adwgh)
20. 7/3/06 South Gippsland Water Dumbalk Tarwin River Methoxychlor 2ug/L (0.667%adwgh)
21. 14/3/07 Barwon Water Gellibrand Lardners Creek 2,4-D 0.2ug/L (0.667%adwgh)
22. 28/3/07 Barwon Water Aireys Inlet Painkalac Creek 2,4-D 0.2ug/L (0.667%adwgh)
Below ADWG Limit
23. 31/1/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 1.3ug/L (0.433%adwgh)
24. 15/12/09 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Inlet Channel 2,4-D 0.09ug/L (0.3%adwgh)
25. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 0.86ug/L (0.2867%adwgh)
26. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 0.67ug/L (0.223%adwgh)
27. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Bostok Outlet Hexazinone 0.58ug/L (0.193%adwgh)
28. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Bostok Outlet Hexazinone 0.56ug/L (0.1867%adwgh)
29. 15/12/09 Barwon Water Matthews Creek 2,4-D 0.05ug/L (0.1667%adwgh)
30. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Bostok Outlet Hexazinone 0.44ug/L (0.1467%adwgh)
31. Dec 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.056ug/L (0.14%adwgh)
32. 11/7/10 Barwon Water Lorne WTP 2,4-D 0.04ug/L (0.1333% adwhg)
33. Mar 06 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.050ug/L (0.125%adwgh)
34. 31/1/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Inlet Hexazinone 0.37ug/L (0.123%adwgh)
35. March 2006 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Atrazine 0.048ug/L (0.12%)
36. Dec 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.045ug/L (0.1125%adwgh)
37. February 2006 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Atrazine 0.044ug/L (0.11%)
38. 1/12/04 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone (0.1067%adwgh)
39. April 06 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.042ug/L (0.105%adwgh)
40. December 2005: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine 0.042ug/L (0.105%)
41. Feb 06 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.041ug/L (0.1025%adwgh)
42. 4/6/02 East Gippsland Water Rocky River (Orbost) Simazine 0.20ug/L (0.1%adwgh)
43. 7/2/00 Melbourne Water Johns Hill Plant Kallista Lindane 0.02ug/L (0.1%adwgh)
44. Jan 06 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.040ug/L (0.1%adwgh)
45. Mar 06 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.040ug/L (0.1%adwgh)
46. 2007/8 WQR Pykes Creek Reservoir (Raw) 2,4-D 0.03ug/L (0.1%adwgh)
47.2/6/10 Barwon Water Meredith WTP 2,4-D 0.03ug/L (0.1%adwgh)
48. 15/12/09 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Inlet Channel 2,4-D 0.03ug/L (0.1% adwgh)
49. Mar 06 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Atrazine 0.039ug/L (0.0975%adwgh)
50. Jan 06 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.038ug/L (0.095%adwgh)
51. Jan 06 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Town Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.038ug/L (0.095%adwgh)
52. April 06 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Atrazine 0.036ug/L (0.09%adwgh)
53. April 2006 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Atrazine 0.036ug/L 0.09%
54. Jan 06 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Town Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.035ug/L (0.0875%adwgh)
55. April 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.033ug/L (0.0825%adwgh)
56. January 2006 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Atrazine 0.033ug/L 0.0825%
57. April 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.032ug/L (0.08%adwgh)
58. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.24ug/L (0.08%adwg)
59. Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.031ug/L (0.0775%adwgh)
60. Feb 06 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.031ug/L (0.0775%adwgh)
61. May 06 Lower Murray Water Red Cliffs supply Atrazine 0.030ug/L (0.075%adwgh)
62. May 06 Lower Murray Water Mildura supply Atrazine 0.030ug/L (0.075%adwgh)
63. May 06 Lower Murray Water Piangil supply Atrazine 0.030ug/L (0.075%adwgh)
64. Nov 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.030ug/L (0.075%adwgh)
65. Mar 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.030ug/L (0.075%adwgh)
66. 31/1/05 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.22ug/L (0.073%adwgh)
67. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.22ug/L (0.073%adwgh)
68. April 04 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.028ug/L (0.07%adwgh)
69. 31/1/05 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.21ug/L (0.07%adwgh)
70. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 0.20ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
71. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 0.20ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
72. 9/11/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.20ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
73. 4/1/06 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.20ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
74. 7/2/06 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir#3 Hexazinone 0.20ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
75. 5/2/07 Western Water Kerrie Reservoir 2,4-D 0.02ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
76. 3/6/10 Barwon Water Apollo Bay WTP 2,4-D 0.02ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
77. 2/6/10 Barwon Water Moorobool WTP 2,4-D 0.02ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
78. 15/12/09 Barwon Water Pennyroyal Creek 2,4-D 0.02ug/L (0.067%adwgh)
79. 4/3/05 Barwon Water Bannockburn Basin Hexazinone 0.19ug/L (0.0633%adwgh)
80. Dec 05 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.025ug/L (0.0625%adwgh)
81. Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie November 2005 Endosulfan 0.0186ug/L, 0.062%
82. Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Atrazine 0.024ug/L (0.06%adwgh)
83. 31/1/05 Barwon Water Upper Stony Creek Res #2 Hexazinone 0.18ug/L (0.06%adwgh)
84. 5/4/06 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.18ug/L (0.06%adwgh)
85. 3/5/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.17ug/L (0.0567%adwgh)
86. Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.022ug/L (0.055%adwgh)
87. Nov 05 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.022ug/L (0.055%adwgh)
88. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.16ug/L (0.053%adwgh)
89. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Upper Stony Creek Res #2 Hexazinone 0.15ug/L (0.05%adwgh)
90. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Upper Stony Creek Res #2 Hexazinone 0.15ug/L (0.05%adwgh)
91. 15/12/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.15ug/L (0.05%adwgh)
92. April 05 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.02ug/L (0.05%adwgh)
93. Feb 06 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Atrazine 0.02ug/L (0.05%adwgh)
94. January 2005: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine 0.02ug/L 0.05%
95. April 2005 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine 0.02ug/L 0.05%
96. March 2005: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine 0.019ug/L 0.0475%
97. Mar 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.018ug/L (0.045%adwgh)
98. 7/2/07 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.13ug/L (0.043%adwgh)
99. Sep 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katatmatite Channel 7/3 Atrazine 0.017ug/L (0.0425%adwgh)
100. Sep 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.016ug/L (0.04%adwgh)
101. 5/4/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.12ug/L (0.04%adwgh)
102. 7/6/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.11ug/L (0.0367%adwgh)
103. 8/8/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.11ug/L (0.0367%adwgh)
104. 7/3/07 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.11ug/L (0.0367%adwgh)
105. 3/5/07 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.11ug/L (0.0367%adwgh)
106. 4/3/05 Barwon Water Montpellier Basin #4 Hexazinone 0.10ug/L (0.0333%adwgh)
107. 9/12/09 Barwon Water Colac WTP 2,4-D 0.01ug/L (0.0333%adwgh)
108. 3/3/10 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP 2,4-D 0.01ug/L (0.0333%adwgh)
109. (2007-08 Annual Report) Lower Murray Water Swan Hill Atrazine 0.012ug/L (0.03%adwgh)
110. October 2005 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Endosulfan 0.0087ug/L, 0.029%
111. 7/3/06 Barwon Water East Moorabool River Hexazinone 0.086ug/L (0.02867%adwgh)
112. 7/6/06 Barwon Water Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Hexazinone 0.084ug/L (0.028%adwgh)
113. Mar 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Atrazine 0.011ug/L (0.0275%adwgh)
114. 31/1/05 Barwon Water Bungal Creek Hexazinone 0.082ug/L (0.0273%adwgh)
115. 5/10/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.082ug/L (0.0273%adwgh)
116. Jan 05 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
117. Oct 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
118. Nov 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
119. Dec 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
120. Feb 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
121. Apr 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
122. Dec 04 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Atrazine 0.01ug/L (0.025%adwgh)
123. February 2005: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine 0.01ug/L 0.025%
124. 3/10/07 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.074ug/L (0.02466%adwgh)
125. 4/1/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.071ug/L (0.02367%adwgh)
126. 6/8/07 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.067ug/L (0.02233%adwgh)
127. 4/7/07 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.06ug/L (0.02%adwgh)
128. 7/3/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.058ug/L (0.0193%adwgh)
129. (2007-08 Annual Report) Lower Murray Water Koondrook Atrazine 0.007ug/L (0.0175%adwgh)
130. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 0.051ug/L (0.017%adwgh)
131. 7/3/05 Barwon Water Bungal Creek Hexazinone 0.047ug/L 2.35%adwg (0.01566%adwgh)
132. (2007-08 Annual Report) Lower Murray Water Mildura Atrazine 0.007ug/L (0.0175%adwgh)
133. 17/10/07 Barwon Water Bostok Outlet Hexazinone 0.036 ug/L (0.012%adwgh)
134. 15/12/06 Barwon Water Moorabool Treatment Hexazinone 0.032ug/L (0.01066%adwgh)
135. 15/8/07 Barwon Water Bostok Outlet Hexazinone 0.029ug/L (0.00966%adwgh)
136. Dec 04 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0027ug/L (0.009%adwgh)
137. 7/11/07 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.026ug/L (0.00866%adwgh)
138. *19/12/07 Barwon Water Barham River 200m u/s river Temephos 0.026ug/L (0.00866%adwgh)
139. Sep 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0024ug/L (0.008%adwgh)
140. Nov 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0023ug/L (0.00767%adwgh)
141. December 2005 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Endosulfan 0.0021ug/L, 0.007%
142. Nov 05 Goulburn Murray Water Tatura Channel 3/5 Endosulfan 0.0020ug/L (0.00667%adwgh)
143. Jan 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0020ug/L (0.00667%adwgh)
144. 5/9/07 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.02ug/L (0.00666%adwgh)
145. 4/6/08 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.02ug/L (0.00666%adwgh)
146. *18/12/07 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Inlet Salt Creek Lane Temephos 0.02ug/L (0.00666%adwgh)
147. 5/12/07 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.019ug/L (0.00633%adwgh)
148. 6/2/08 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Hexazinone 0.018ug/L (0.006%adwgh)
149. 17/10/07 Barwon Water Korweinguboora Outlet Hexazinone 0.016ug/L (0.006%adwgh)
150. Oct 04 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0017ug/L (0.00566%adwgh)
151. Dec 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0017ug/L (0.00566%adwgh)
152. Jan 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0017ug/L (0.00566%adwgh)
153. Nov 04 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
154. Feb 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
155. Mar 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
156. Apr 05 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
157. Jan 06 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
158. Feb 06 Goulburn Murray Water Corop Rochester Channel 1 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
159. Oct 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
160. Nov 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
161. Dec 04 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
162. Feb 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
163. Mar 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
164. Apr 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
165. Sep 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
166. Dec 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
167. Jan 06 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
168. Feb 06 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
169. Feb 06 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
170. Sep 05 Goulburn Murray Water West Boort Channel 5 Endosulfan 0.0015ug/L (0.005%adwgh)
171. *18/12/07 Barwon Water Pennyroyal Creek Temephos 0.014ug/L (0.00466%adwgh)
172. *19/12/07 Barwon Water Barham River @ Pumping Station Temephos 0.014ug/L (0.00466%adwgh)
173 . 9/10/08 Barwon Water Moorabool WTP Combined Raw Water Hexazinone 0.014ug/L (0.00466%adwgh)
174. *18/12/07 Barwon Water Callahans Creek Temephos 0.013ug/L (0.00433%adwgh)
175. *19/12/07 Barwon Water Barham River Marengo Basin Temephos 0.012ug/L (0.004%adwgh)
176. 4/9/07 Barwon Water Lorne Hexazinone 0.012ug/L (0.004%adwgh)
177. *18/12/07 Barwon Water Matthews Creek Temephos 0.011ug/L 0.0037%adwg (0.0037%adwgh)
178. Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water Katamatite Channel 7/3 Endosulfan 0.0007ug/L (0.00233%adwgh)
179. November 2004: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie Trace level Endosulfan
180. August 2005 Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine trace
181. October 2005: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine trace
182. November 2005: Goulburn Murray Water Goulburn Weir/Nagambie atrazine trace
No ADWG
Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Bifenthrin 100ug/L
Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Taufluvalinate 75ug/L
Oct 05 Goulburn Murray Water Kerang Channel 14/2 Esfenvalerate 65ug/L
Oct 98 Goulburn Valley Water Mooroopna Offtake ? Unidentifed Peaks
13/9/00 Goulburn Valley Water Violet Town Hexachlorobenzene 0.004ug/L
12/7/00 Goulburn Valley Water Picola Hexachlorobenzene 0.003ug/L
2/8/00 Goulburn Valley Water Katunga Hexachlorobenzene 0.003ug/L
9/2/05 Goulburn Valley Water Shepparton Hexachlorobenzene 0.002ug/L
18/9/07 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Channel @ 8 Mile 245TCP
18/9/07 Barwon Water Matthews Creek MCPA 0.07ug/L
18/9/07 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc Inlet Channel MCPA 0.04ug/L
18/9/07 Barwon Water Pennyroyal Creek MCPA 0.01ug/L
18/9/07 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc @ Salt Creek Lane 4, chlorophenoxy acetic acid 0.04ug/L
18/9/07 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc @ Brickmakers Rd 4, chlorophenoxy acetic acid 0.01ug/L
Nov 02 Macalister River DEET 0.0207ug/L
4/9/09 Barwon Water Birregurra WTP MCPA 0.02ug/L
9/12/09 Barwon Water Colac WTP 4, chlorophenoxy acetic acid 0.05ug/L
2/12/09 Barwon Water Forrest WTP MCPA 0.06ug/L
9/12/09 Barwon Water Gellibrand WTP 4, chlorphenoxy acetic acid 0.05ug/L
15/12/09 Barwon Water Matthews Creek (Geelong) MCPA 0.07ug/L
15/12/09 Barwon Water Pennyroyal Creek (Geelong) MCPA 0.01ug/L
15/12/09 Barwon Water Wurdee Boluc @ Salt Creek Lane 4, chlorophenoxy acetic acid 0.01ug/L


Dec 07: All land use within Moorabool (Sheoaks) and Stony Creek Proclaimed Water Supply Catchments. Light Tan=cropping areas, Dark tan=grazing areas. Orange=canola planted in 07.

October 2008: Canola now being grown adjacent to Wurdee Boluc Inlet Channel (5km west of Deans Marsh) possibly meaning higher potential for pollution from agrochemicals into Geelong drinking water. This is the first instance recorded of canola being grown in such close proximity to the channel and could represent a new hazard to water quality if grown in large enough areas, particularly areas upslope of the supply channel. The channel can be seen running through the yellow canalo field.

Cropping 1km upstream of Bostok Reservoir- Geelong Water supply.

Sep 08: Stony Creek Reservoir #3 Bone dry.
Time covered in FoI request: 28/10/99 - 17/9/07.
51 positive pesticide results. Most of the results relate to hexazinone leaching from Korweingaboora pine plantation. 5 positive readings for 2,4-D, 1 positive result for Glyphosate and 1 positive result for Dieldrin.
Pesticides Currently Tested for by Barwon Water
Organochlorines: 4,4-DDD, 4,4-DDE, 4,4-DDT, Aldrin, BHC-a, BHC-b, BHC-d, Cis-Chlordane, Dieldrin, Endosulphan 1, Endosulphan 2, Endosulphan Sulphate, Endrin, Endrin Aldehyde, Heptachlor, Heptachlor Epoxide, Hexachlorobenzene, Lindane, Methoxychlor, Trans-Chlordane. Organophosphorus: Chlopyrifos, Coumphanos, Demeton-S, Diazinon, Dichlorvos, EPN, Fensulfonthion, Fenthion, Malathion, Methyl Parathion, Monocrotophos, Parathion, Phorate, Prohos, Ronnel, Tetrachlorvinphos, Tetraethyldithiopyrophos, Trichlorinate, Tukuthion. Herbicides: 2,4,5-T, 2,4,5-TP, 2,4,6-T, 2,4-D, 2,4-DB, 2,4-DP, 2,6-D, 4-Chlorophenoxy acetic acid, Dicamba, MCBP, Mecoprop, Trichlopyr. Herbicides 2: Clopyralid, Hexazinone, Molinate, Picloran, Temephos Herbicides 3: Paraquat, Diquat NMI Org 1: Atrazine, Chlofenvinphos, Diuron, Endosulphan, Propiconazole, Glyphosate. NMI Org 4: Mancozeb, Metiram, Amitrole. NMI Org 5: Qunitozene, Phorate, Pirimicarb, Chlorothalonil, Propachlor.
Testing varies at different locations, basically done on a quarterly basis.
Largest regional urban water authority. Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc supplies 70% of water for Geelong, Bellarine Peninsula & Surf Coast. Moorabool System supplies Anakie, Staughton Vale, Bannockburn, Gheringhap, Teesdale, Shelford, Inverleigh & Geelong. Otways supplies Colac & Cressy. Gellibrand, Aireys Inlet/Fairhaven, Apollo Bay/Skenes Creek & Lorne have their own water supplies.
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Nov 23 2009: Anglesea Aquifer Kicks Off
http://www.theage.com.au/environment/water-issues/angelsea-aquifer-kicks-off-20091122-isui.html
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Barwon Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
| Town | Source of Water | Comments |
| Aireys Inlet | Painkalac Creek | 2,4-D traces 2007 |
| Anakie/Staughton Vale | Moorabool System | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Anglesea | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Apollo Bay | West Barham River | |
| Ballan | Bostok Reservoir? (Central Highlands Water?) | Cropping |
| Bannockburn/Gheringhap | Moorabool River | cropping |
| Barwon Heads | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Beeac | Olangolah Reservoir | DDT recorded Olangolah 1994 Should be high quality |
| Birregurra | Barwon River (Otways) | |
| Breamlea | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Colac | Olangolah Reservoir | DDT recorded Olangolah 1994 Should be high quality |
| Coragulac | Olangolah Reservoir | DDT recorded Olangolah 1994 Should be high quality |
| Cressy | Olangolah Reservoir | DDT recorded Olangolah 1994 Should be high quality |
| Drysdale | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Forrest | Barwon River (Otways) | |
| Geelong |
Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc Moorabool System |
Open aquaduct/farming |
| Gellibrand | Lardners Creek | Midway Plantations/farming, 2,4-D traces 2007 |
| Gerangamete | Barwon River (Otways) | ? |
| Indented Head | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Inverleigh | Moorabool System | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Lara | Moorabool System | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Leopold | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Lethbridge | Moorabool River | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Lorne | St George River/Allen Reservoir | |
| Meredith | Moorabool River | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Moorabool | Moorabool System | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Moriac | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Mount Moriac | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Ocean Grove | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Pirron Yallock | Olangolah Reservoir | DDT recorded Olangolah 1994 Should be high quality |
| Point Lonsdale | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Portarlington | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Queenscliff | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Shelford/Teesdale | Moorabool System | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| Skenes Creek | West Barham River | |
| Steiglitz | Moorabool System | Hancock Pine, cropping |
| St.Leonards | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Torquay | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |
| Winchelsea | Barwon River (Otways)/ Wurdee Boluc | Open aquaduct/farming |

Potato growing inside Ballarat's water supply

Map with Ballarat's water supply highlighted. Light green=native forest, dark brown=radiata pine plantations managed by Central Highlands Water, dark blue=reservoirs, orange=cropping, dark orange=potatoes 06/07, Tan=grazing. The cropping, grazing and potatoe boundaries outlines change from year to year and as such are only approximate. The catchment is dominated by cropping, yet Central Highlands Water only test for two currently used pesticides.

Same colour coding for Lal Lal catchment which also supplies drinking water to Ballarat. Lal Lal is dominated by pasture, with cropping mainly in the northern half.

Land Use Map of Goulburn System above Lake Nagambie. Ballarat and Bendigo are now connected to the Goulburn River via the Goldfields Superpipe (Goulburn Weir/Waranga Basin and Waranga Western Channel). Tan=Improved Pasture, Orange=Cropping, Purple=Vineyards, Brown=Pine plantations, Green=Puckapunyal Military Base.

Land Use map of Goulburn Weir to Colbinnabin. This is how water is transferred from Goulburn Weir to Bendigo/Ballarat.
Time covered in FoI request: 3/10/06 - 7/12/07
Pesticides tested once a year (November) for; DDT, Aldrin and Dieldrin, Chlordane, Hexachlorobenzene, Heptachlor, Heptachlor Epoxide, Lindane, Methoxychlor, 2,4-D, Atrazine.
No positive pesticide results.
Location of test sites: Amphitheatre, Avoca Clear Water Storage “CWS”, Beaufort CWS, Blackwood CWS, Clunes CWS, Daylesford Low Level Basin, Dean CWS, Forest Hill CWS, Glut-Raglan Pipeline (Raglan), Lal Lal CWS, Landsborough Reservoir, Learmonth CWS, Maryborough CWS, Waubra CWS, White Swan CWS.
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Pesticides Commonly Used in the Vegetable Industry in Victoria
More information on Central Highlands Water here
Much of the Ballarat Water supply (excluding Lal Lal Reservoir catchment) is covered with potato crops and pine plantations. The following pesticides are likely to be used within the catchment. Note that Central Highlands Water only test for two currently used pesticides; 2,4-D and Atrazine.
Information on pesticides sourced from Pesticide Action Network
|
Type
|
|
PAN BAD ACTOR
|
ACUTE TOXICITY
|
CARCINOGEN
|
CHOLINESTERASE INHIBITOR
|
GROUND WATER CONTAMINANT
|
DEVELOPMENTAL OR REPRODUCTIVE TOXIN
|
ENDOCRINE DISRUPTOR
|
|
|
2,4-D
|
Chlorophenoxy Acid or Ester
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Possible
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
Suspected
|
|
Azoxystrobin
|
Strobin
|
F
|
Not Listed
|
Not Acutely Toxic
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Chlorothalonil
|
Substituted Benzene
|
F
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Clethodim
|
Cyclohexenone Derivative
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
?
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Clopyralid
|
Pyridinecarboxylic Acid
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Cyanazine
|
Triazine
|
H
|
Yes
|
Moderate
|
Possible
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Suspected
|
|
Diquat
|
Bipyridylium
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Fludioxinil
|
F
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Unclassifiable
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
|
Fluroxypur
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
|
Glyphosate
|
Phosphonoglycine
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
Hexazinone
|
Triazinone
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Unclassifiable
|
No
|
Yes
|
?
|
?
|
|
MCPA
|
Chlorophenoxy acid or ester
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Possible
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
Metalaxyl
|
Xylylalanine
|
F
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Methamidophos
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not Likely
|
Yes
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Metribuzin
|
Triazinone
|
H
|
Yes
|
Moderate
|
Unclassifiable
|
No
|
Potential
|
Yes
|
Suspected
|
|
Metsulfuron Methyl
|
Sulfonylurea
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Paraquat
|
Bipyridylium
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Permethrin
|
Pyrethroid
|
I
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Possible
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
Herbicides used in CHW pine plantations in water supply; Under Canopy Weed Control: Weedmaster Duo (Glyphosate 360g/L), Roundup Biactive (Glyphosate 360g/L), Brush-Off (Metsulfuron Methyl 600g/Kg).
Pine Plantation Establishment: Velpar DF (Hexazinone 750g/kg). Strip or spot application (spot application using Velmac G) depending on site requirements at 5kg/ha. The amount applied is to 33% of total area (due to plantation rows).
2nd year pine establishment: Velmac G (hexazinone 200g/ka). Spot applied on each tree in the plantation row at 2g/tree. 2.6kg/ha (1300 trees ha)
Gastion Tablets (Aluninium phosphide)
http://www.chw.net.au/geog_2003.htm
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Central HighlandsWater. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
|
Town
|
Source of Water
|
Comments
|
| Adelaide Lead | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Alfredton | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Alma | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Amphitheatre | (Amphitheatre Res - non potable) | |
| Avoca | (Sugarloaf Reservoir/Lead Reservoir/Bung Bung Bore) | ? Poor quality repuation |
| Ballan | Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | Potatoes, cropping, plantation |
| Ballarat | Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | Potatoes, cropping, plantation |
| Ballarat East | Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | Potatoes, cropping, plantation |
| Ballarat North | Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | Potatoes, cropping, plantation |
| Ballarat South | Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | Potatoes, cropping, plantation |
| Beaufort | (Cave Hill Creek, Troys Reservoir) | |
| Betley | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Black Hill | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Blackwood | Barry’s Reef (Kyneton Creek, Long Gully Creek, Blackwood Bore) | |
| Brown Hill | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Bungaree | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Buninyong | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Cambrian Hill | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Canadian | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Cardigan Village | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Carisbrook | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Carngham | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Clunes | (Bores) | |
| Corindhap | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Creswick | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Daisy Hill | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Daylesford | Stewarts Creek/Wombat Reservoir & Hepburn Reservoir/Bullarto Reservior | |
| Dean | Dean Reservoir/Dean Bore | |
| Delacombe | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Dereel | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Enfield | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Eureka | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Flagstaff Hill | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Fiskville | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Forest Hills | Bore | ? |
| Glemore | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Golden Point | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Gordon | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Haddon | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Havelock | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Hepburn | Stewarts Creek/Wombat Reservoir & Hepburn Reservoir/Bullarto Reservior | |
| Hepburn Springs | Stewarts Creek/Wombat Reservoir & Hepburn Reservoir/Bullarto Reservior | |
| Invermay | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Kingston | Bore | |
| Lal Lal | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Landsborough | (Landsborough Reservoir, Landsborough Bore (drought relief))non potable | |
| Learmonth | (Bores) | |
| Lexton | (Lexton Reservoir) | |
| Linton | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Little Bendigo | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Magpie | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Majorca | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Maryborough | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir, bore water from May 2008 | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Miners Rest | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Mitchell Park | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Mt Clear | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Mt Egerton | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Mt Helen | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Mt Pleasant | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Mt Rowan | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Napoleons | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Navarre | (GW) Franks Gully Reservoir?/Landsborough | |
| Nerrina | Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir | Potatoes, cropping, plantation |
| Newlyn | Bore | |
| Nintingbool | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Pittong | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Raglan | (Cave Hill to Musical Gully Reservoir Pipeline) non potable | |
| Redbank | (Redbank Reservoir, Redbank Bore (drought relief)) non potable | |
| Redan | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Rokewood | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Ross Creek | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Rowsley | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Scarsdale | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Sebastapool | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Skipton | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Simson/Bet Bet | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Smeaton | Bore | |
| Smythes Creek | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Smythesdale | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Snake Valley | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Soldiers Hill | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Springmount | Bore | |
| Talbot | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Timor | Tullaroop Reservoir/Evansford Reservoir, Talbot Reservoir | cropping, pines in upper catchment |
| Wallace | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Warrenheip | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Waubra | (bore) | |
| Wendouree | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Wendouree West | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Windermere | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Woodman's Hill | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |
| Yendon. | Wilson Reservoir, Beales Reservoir, Moorabool Reservoir, Lal Lal Reservoir Ballarat System (Kirks Reservoir, Gong Reservoir, Pincotts Reservoir) | some croppping, spuds, CHW plantation |

Map of Bendigo Water Supply: Tan = Improved Pasture, Orange=cropping, Yellow=Bluegum plantations. The southern portion of the catchment is now used exclusively by Kyneton and Castlemaine.

Land Use Map of Goulburn System above Lake Nagambie. Ballarat and Bendigo are now connected to the Goulburn River via the Goldfields Superpipe (Goulburn Weir/Waranga Basin and Waranga Western Channel). Tan=Improved Pasture, Orange=Cropping, Purple=Vineyards, Brown=Pine plantations, Green=Puckapunyal Military Base.

Land Use map of Goulburn Weir to Colbinnabin. This is how water is transferred from Goulburn Weir to Bendigo/Ballarat.

Lauriston Reservoir
Time covered in FoI request: 1/7/04 – 28/11/07
Note: no testing for Atrazine, which Goulburn Murray Water detected at Rochester/Corop (mar 05, sep-oct 05 & feb-apr 06). Endosulfan detected GMW Oct 04-apr 05, sep 05, nov 05-feb 06).
No testing for Atrazine,which Goulburn Murray Water detected at West Boort (oct 04-dec 04, feb 05-apr 05, sep 05-oct 05, mar 06 – apr 06). Endosulfan detected GMW Oct 04-jan 05, mar 05-apr 05 sep 05, dec 05-mar 06).
Current Pesticide Testing
Raw Water: Test for 2,4-D @5µg/L, Aldrin, B-a-Pyrene, Chlor, DDT, Dieldrin, Heptachlor, Lindane at most locations once a year. Less than half locations get tested once per six months.
Customer Tap Water Tests 1/7/04 to present day: Test for 2,4-D @5µg/L, Aldrin, Chlordane, DDT, Dieldrin, Epoxide, Gamma HCH, Heptachlor, Benzo(a)pyrene mostly every three months.
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Vineyards in Australian here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Apple and Pear Orchard Pesticides
Pesticides Commonly Used in the Vegetable Industry in Victoria
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Coliban Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
|
Town
|
Source of Water
|
Comments
|
| Axedale | Campaspe River | |
| Bealiba | Loddon River | |
| Bendigo (incl Belvoir Park, Big hill, Edwards Rd Tank, Huntly, Marong, Sandhurst, Specimen Hill) | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) via Coliban Main Channel into Sandhurst Reservoir. Supplementary supply from Lake Eppalock via the Eppalock-Bendigo Pipeline into Sandhurst Reservoir. Waranga Channel. | Activated Carbon |
| Boort | Goulburn System - Waranga Western Channel | |
| Borung(u) | Wimmera System | Untreated |
| Bridgewater | Loddon River | |
| Campbells Creek | Coliban River | |
| Castlemaine | Malmsbury Reservoir (via Coliban Main Channel) into McCay Reservoir, via the Poverty Gully Channel. McCay Reservoir is primarily used as a service reservoir. | Activated Carbon, Ozone |
| Chewton | Coliban River | |
| Cohuna | Gunbower Creek | |
| Dingee(u) | GMW Pyramid No.1 Channel | Untreated |
| Dunolly | Loddon River | |
| Eaglehawk | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
|
Echuca |
Murray River | |
| Elmore | Ground water | Deep Lead GW |
| Elphingstone | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
| Epsom | Coliban River | |
| Fryerstown | Malmsbury Reservoir (via Coliban Main Channel) into McCay Reservoir, via the Poverty Gully Channel. McCay Reservoir is primarily used as a service reservoir. | |
| Goornong | Campaspe River | |
| Gunbower | Taylors Creek | |
| Guildford | Supplied from the Coliban System of Storages | |
| Harcourt | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
| Heathcote | Lake Eppalock, with water transferred into Caledonia Reservior which is primarily used as a service reservoir. | |
| Huntly | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
| Inglewood | Loddon River | |
| Jarklin(u) | Loddon River | Untreated |
| Kangaroo Flat | Coliban River | |
| Korong Vale | GWMW Channel | ? |
| Kyenton | Coliban River. Lauriston Reservoir. | Activated Carbon |
| Laanecoorie | Loddon River | |
| Leitchville | GMW channel, Gunbower Creek | |
| Lockington | GMW Channel | |
| Maiden Gully | Coliban River | |
| Maldon | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
| Malmsbury | Coliban River | |
| Macorna(u) | GMW Channel | Untreated |
| Marong | Supplied from the Coliban System of Storages | |
| Mitiamo(u) | GMW channel | Untreated |
| Mysia(u) | GMW Western Waranga Channel Channel | Untreated |
| Newstead | Supplied from the Coliban System of Storages | |
| Pyramid Hill | GMW channel | Activated Carbon |
| Park Valley | Coliban River | |
| Raywood | CW Channel | |
| Rochester | GMW Waranga Western Channel/Campaspe No2 Channel | |
| Sebastian(u) | Supplied from the Coliban System of Storages | Untreated |
| Serpentine | Loddon River | |
| Strathfieldsaye | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
| Taradale | Supplied primarily from the Coliban System of Storages (Upper Coliban, Lauriston & Malmsbury) | |
| Tarnagulla | Loddon River | |
| Tooborac | Coliban River | |
| Trentham | Groundwater | Activated Carbon |
| Tylden |
Coliban River. Lauriston Reservoir |
|
| Wedderburn | Wimmera System | ? |
| Wychitella(u) | Wimmera System | Untreated |

Campaspe No. 2 Main Channel - Water supply for Rochester

Orbost water supply has ~200ha of Harris Daishowa plantations
Time covered in FoI request: 1995 - 28/12/07
Simazine detected 0.2µg/L August 2002 Rocky River catchment - Orbost Water Supply.
Current Testing Regime for Pesticides
None since 2003. "EGW is still considering the worth of ongoing monitoring for pesticides..." Established a process with Parks Victoria to ensure that (they) are informed of any chemical usage in catchments about offtakes (eg ragwort, blackberry spraying).
Monitoring for pesticides has been undertaken by EGW. Electronic data goes back to 2000. Hardcopy lab reports go back to 1995, with samples taken on a quarterly basis, from 1995 to 2001. Since that time samples have been taken in July and August 2002, February, March and July 2003. "The pesticides analysed for were consistent with World Health Organisation Guidelines for Water 1996 and the previous MoU with predecessors of DSE. These were; 2,4-D, 4-4-DDT, Aldrin, trans & cis chlordane, dieldrin, heptachlor epoxide, lindane and methoxychlor, as well as a general pesticide scan. If the pesticide scan identified the presence of a substance it was pursued further for identification, however no traces of concern were found". "Following the development of the Safe Drinking Water Act and the Risk Assessment process that EGW completed for its water supply catchments in 2003/4, it was determined that, as evidenced by the absence in historic data, the risk of pesticide presence in the water supplies was very low."

Buchan River upstream of Buchan.
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Table of places supplied with drinking water from East Gippsland Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
|
Town
|
Source of Supply
|
Comments
|
| Bairnsdale | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Bemm River | Bemm River | Mainly native forest |
| Bruthen | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Buchan | Buchan River | Some farms upstream of uptake |
| Cann River | Cann River | Some farms upstream of uptake |
| Dinner Plain Village Resort | Two bores west of Resort | |
| Eagle Point | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Johnsonville | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Kalimna | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Lakes Entrance | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Lake Tyers Aboriginal Trust | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Lake Tyers Beach | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Lindenow | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Mallacoota | Betka River | Mainly native forest |
| Marlo | Rocky River/Brobribb River | ~200ha SEFE bluegum plantations in catchment |
| Metung | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Mossiface | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Newlands Arm | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Newmerella | Rocky River/Brobribb River | ~200ha SEFE bluegum plantations in catchment |
| Nicholson | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Nowa Nowa | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Omeo | Butchers Creek | Mainly native forest |
| Orbost | Rocky River/Brobribb River | ~200ha SEFE plantations in catchment |
| Paynesville | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Raymond Island | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Sarsfield | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Swan Reach | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
| Swifts Creek | Tambo River | Some farms upstream of uptake |
| Wiseleigh | Mitchell River (Woodglen Reservoir) | Entirely sourced downstream of National Park |
In the study, “Horticultural Pesticides in residues in water. Research report No.146 Department Agriculture November 1993”, which focused on horticultural activities in the Mitchell River, one site was located upstream of the extensive cropping area of the Mitchell River floodplain near Lindenow. One would have thought that pesticide residues would have been detected downstream of the crops, however Site 1, was located in very close proximity to the Mitchell River pumping station. In 1992 Atrazine was detected at this location at 0.02µg/L. In 1993 Endosulfan was detected at this location at 0.01µg/L and 0.014µg/L. One can assume that the pesticides were washed upstream with the potential of being taken up via offtake.
In the follow up study, “Horticultural pesticide residues in water. A survey of pesticide residues conducted in Gippsland Victoria, 1994 Agriculture Victoria, Research Report Series No. 146 Feb 1995” Dieldrin was detected at the upstream site at 0.02µg/L, DDT at 0.017µg/L.

Easterbrook Creek Gippsland. Thorpdale Water Supply dominated by potato farms and cattle grazing

Water supplies for Narracan Creek (Moe, Newborough, Trafalgar, Yallourn North and Yarragon) and Easterbrook Creek (Thorpdale). Orange is approximate locations for potato crops. Green = native forest, Tan = pine plantations, Purple = plantations managed by Hancock Victorian Plantations, Yellow is hardwood plantations managed by Hancock Victorian Plantations. Blue represents grazing/potatoes.
Time covered in FoI requests: 1998 - 22/07/06
Update: Cattle Insect Repellent DEET (N, N-diethyltoluamide) detected November 2002 0.0207µg/L Newry Creek - upstream drinking water offtake Maffra/Stratford). Results published July 2008 here. No ADWG limits for DEET.
Simazine detected at 30 parts per billion (28/29 November2007) in grab sample at the Latrobe River near Rosedale in 'Pilot Study of Agrochemicals in West Gippsland Waterways - 2007'. This could represent the highest detection of simazine on mainland Australia. Simazine also detected at 160ug/l (over 21 day period) and Ethion (over 21 day period) June 2007 at Moe Drain. Hexazinone detected at 10ug/l (over 21 day period) and simazine 195ug/L (over 21 day period) December 2007 at Latrobe River Rosedale.
Pesticide Testing Regime:
Tested once (March 2005) for; Dichlorvos, Diazinon, Chlorpyrifos, Malathion, Fenitrothion, Bromofos Ethyl, Methidathion, Ethion @ Boolara, Briagalong, Coongulla/Glenmaggie, Heyfield, Maffra, Mirboo North, Moe, Sale, Seaspray, Thorpdale, Traralgon, Warragul, Willow Grove.
No positive pesticide results.
Large potato land holdings are within water supplies such in Easterbrook Creek and Narracan Creek. The following pesticides are used in potato growing in Gippsland. Information on pesticides sourced from Pesticide Action Network
|
Type
|
|
PAN BAD ACTOR
|
ACUTE TOXICITY
|
CARCINOGEN
|
CHOLINESTERASE INHIBITOR
|
GROUND WATER CONTAMINANT
|
DEVELOPMENTAL OR REPRODUCTIVE TOXIN
|
ENDOCRINE DISRUPTOR
|
|
|
2,4-D
|
Chlorophenoxy Acid or Ester
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Possible
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
Suspected
|
|
Azoxystrobin
|
Strobin
|
F
|
Not Listed
|
Not Acutely Toxic
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Chlorothalonil
|
Substituted Benzene
|
F
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Clethodim
|
Cyclohexenone Derivative
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
?
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Clopyralid
|
Pyridinecarboxylic Acid
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Cyanazine
|
Triazine
|
H
|
Yes
|
Moderate
|
Possible
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Suspected
|
|
Diquat
|
Bipyridylium
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Fludioxinil
|
F
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Unclassifiable
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
|
Fluroxypur
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
|
Glyphosate
|
Phosphonoglycine
|
H
|
Not Listed
|
Slight
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
MCPA
|
Chlorophenoxy acid or ester
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Possible
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
Metalaxyl
|
Xylylalanine
|
F
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Methamidophos
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not Likely
|
Yes
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Metribuzin
|
Triazinone
|
H
|
Yes
|
Moderate
|
Unclassifiable
|
No
|
Potential
|
Yes
|
Suspected
|
|
Paraquat
|
Bipyridylium
|
H
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Not Likely
|
No
|
Potential
|
?
|
?
|
|
Permethrin
|
Pyrethroid
|
I
|
Not Listed
|
Moderate
|
Possible
|
No
|
?
|
?
|
?
|

Water supply for Maffra and Stratford (Macalister River). Green represents native forests. Orange represents Irrigated Pasture. The rest of the water supply is dominated by dryland grazing (light blue).

Offtake for Maffra water supply, pumped from Macalister River and downstream of ~ 5000ha of irrigated pasture.

Tyers River Water Supply which feeds into Moondarra Reseroir.Eleven regional towns are reliant on Moondarra Reservoir for drinking water. Orange represents pine plantations managed by Gippsland Water, Tan represents grazing pasture. Purple represents pine plantations managed by Hancock Victorian Plantations. Blue represents native forest.
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Pesticides Commonly Used in the Vegetable Industry in Victoria
1/6/07: SRW Tests Show Chemicals
Concerns expressed in May 2006 Gippsland Water Submission regarding Review of the Agriculture and Veterinary Chemicals (Control of Use) Regulation 1996; "Records are kept for the application of restricted chemical products, but not for the other commonly used products that have environmental or health implications. Gippsland Water has had difficulty in obtaining information on the chemicals in use within a catchment area upstream of a Water Treatment plant and town water supply...Currently there is no common record of chemical products that are likely to be applied in agricultural areas within potable water catchments."
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Gippsland Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
| Town | Source of Water | Comments |
| Boisdale | Macalister River | Irrigated Pasture/Dairy |
| Boolara | Walkley Creek/O'Grady Creek | Dairy/plantations? |
| Briagalong | Bore (Boisdale Aquifer) | |
| Buln Buln | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Churchill | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Coongulla | Lake Glenmaggie + tankered water from Heyfield Dec 06-Feb 07 | |
| Cowwarr | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Darnum | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Drouin | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Erica | Trigger Creek | |
| Glengarry | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) + tankered water from Heyfield Dec 06-Feb 07 | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Glenmaggie | Lake Glenmaggie | |
| Heyfield | Thomson River | |
| Jumbuk | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Maffra | Macalister River | Irrigated Pasture/Dairy |
| Mirboo North | Little Morwell River (North Arm) | |
| Moe | Tanjil River & Narracan Creek | Potatoes |
| Morwell | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Neerim South | Tarago River | |
| Newborough | Tanjil River & Narracan Creek | Potatoes |
| Nilma | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Noojee | Deep Creek/Loch River + Tanjil River | Hancock plantations |
| Rawson | Trigger Creek | |
| Rokeby | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Rosedale | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Sale | Bore Boisdale Aquifer | Depends on depth of bores |
| Seaspray | Merrimans Creek + trucked water from Sale Dec 06 -Feb 07 | Hancock plantations/dairy |
| Stratford | Macalister River | Irrigated Pasture/Dairy |
| Thorpdale | Easterbrook Creek + bore Dec 06 - Feb 07 | Potatoes |
| Toongabbie | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Trafalgar | Tanjil River & Narracan Creek | Potatoes |
| Traralgon | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Traralgon South/Hazelwood North | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Tyers | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |
| Warragul | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Warragul South | Pederson Weir (Tarago River)+ Tarago Reservoir | |
| Warrak | Bore Boisdale Aquifer | |
| Willow Grove | Tanjil River | ? |
| Yallourn North | Tanjil River & Narracan Creek | Potatoes/farmland |
| Yarragon | Tanjil River & Narracan Creek | Potatoes/farmland |
| Yinnar | Moondarra Reservoir (Tyers River) | Gippsland Water plantations |

Time covered in FoI request: 1996 - 3/1/08
Goulburn Murray Water does not supply drinking water, it supplies untreated raw water to its water suppliers, Goulburn Valley Water, North East Water, Coliban Water and Lower Murray Water. The water authorities then sell water to domestic users as well as supply and treat the water.
Lake Nagambie, Murray River, Broken Creek all sprayed with Glyphosate to control aquatic weeds. Spraying also occurs in irrigation channels, drains etc. These channels may also be used for drinking water.
Goulburn Murray Water has carried out investigations into the use of pesticides in some of their region. Some of the results of these reports were used in determining potential pollution of drinking water sources. Most notably;
CSIRO/Goulburn Murray Water "First-Tier Assessment of the Risks Associated with Pesticides used in the Goulburn Murray Irrigation Areas" September 2003. Report looks at the risks associated with pesticide use in the GMW Irrigation Areas to water quality and through water quality changes to humans, stock, aquaculture, food industries, pastures, and aquatic flora and fauna and aquatic ecosystems". Determined top ten pesticides posing highest overall risk; azinphos-methyl, copper hydroxide, parathion methyl, chlorpyrifos, omethoate, esfenvalerarate, methomyl, thiram, bifenthrin, mancozeb. In terms of drinking water;
p2 "The relative risk of off-site migration of pesticides via run-off from irrigated area was also assessed. Please note that it was not included in the combined risk, as the run-off does not normally reach the irrigation channels, especially because the irrigation channels are almost universally at a higher elevation than surrounding land. However, at certain locations, not provided with a G-MW drainage service, irrigation customers are sometimes permitted to pump flood waters that accumulate following heavy rain into adjacent irrigation channels."
"Pesticide Monitoring in Goulburn-Murray Waters Irrigation Supply Channels Covering the Six Irrigation Areas [2004-2006 Irrigation Season Study Report] June 2006" Published Primary Industries Research Victoria Environmental Health and Chemistry DPI Werribee. Looked at pesticide and heavy metals monitoring at 15 potential risk sites within six Goulburn Murray Water irrigation areas in northern Vic during 04-05 and 05-06. Five sites were located upstream of water supplies; Katamatite (Channel 7/3), Tatura (Channel 3/5), Corop/Rochester (Rochester Channel Waranga Western Channel), West Boort (Channel 5 Waranga Western Channel).
Positive detections of Atrazine, Endosulfan and Chlorpyrifos. p1 "The CSIRO study recommended monitoring of 10 high risk pesticides in G-MW irrigation channels to establish high risk sites within G-MW irrigation areas. However, both CSIRO and DPI (State Chemistry Laboratory) suggested inclusion of some medium risk pesticides such as endosulfan, atrazine, molinate during pesticide monitoring in channels".
Goulburn Murray Water "Broken Creek Herbicide Residue Testing, 2003-06 Date 1/10/06 Document No: 2034856" Broken Creek supplies drinking water to Numurkah, Nathalia and Wunghu. It is also used for irrigation and drainage services and because it is slow moving and shallow it can be infested with aquatic weeds, especially Arrowhead and Cumbungi. GWM have permits from the APVMA to control weeds in this creek with Glyphosate and 2,4-D (2,4-D has not been used for some years). Positive readings for Glyphosate were detected on 8/5/06 at Thomson Rd, which supposedly is upstream of Nathalia's drinking water supply.
More information on Goulburn Murray Water here
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Vineyards in Australian here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Apple and Pear Orchard Pesticides
Pesticides Commonly Used in the Vegetable Industry in Victoria
Waranga Western Channel spraying Weedmaster at different locations on the channel system possibly once a month. Weedmaster used to kill bathurst burr, briar rose, paterson's cure, jointed rush, cumbungi, sedge, cane grass, water couch, jointed rush

Tatura Water Treatment Plant sourcing from Channel 3/5. Atrazine and Endosulphan at low levels have been recorded in this channel
FoI dates: 1996 to 31/1/07 (Information prior to 1996 not available on any electronic database, and is therefore not readily available.
Sampling done quarterly for potable water systems and twice yearly for non-potable systems.
9 positive samples; 2,4-D, Hexachlorobenzene (4), Pentachlorphenol (2), Heptachlor and one unidentified peaks.
Note: no testing for Atrazine, which Goulburn Murray Water detected at Katamatite (sep 05-mar 06 & oct 06) and Tatura (Jan 05, Apr 05, Dec 06-Apr 06) . Chlorpyrifos also detected by Goulburn Murray Water at Katamatite Jan 06. Endosulfan detected GMW Tatura Nov 05 and Katamatite Sep 05. Note: Positive results for Glyphosate Broken Creek 1/10/06 from Goulburn Murray Water not detected by Goulburn Valley Water tests
Current Pesticide Testing Regimes:
4,4-DDD, 4-4-DDE, 4-4-DDT, Aldrin, BHC (alpha isomer), BHC (beta isomer), BHC (delta isomer), cis-Chlordane, Dieldrin, Endosulfan I, Endosulfan II, Endosulfan Sulphate, Endrin, Endrin aldehyde, Heptachlor, Heptachlor Epoxide, Hexachlorobenzene, Lindane, Methoxychlor, trans-Chlordane, Chlorpyrifos, Coumphanos, Demeton-S, Diazinon, Dichlorvos, EPN, Fensulphothion, Fenthion, Malathion, Methyl Parathion, Monocrotophos, Parathion, Phorate, Prophos, Ronnel, Tetrachlovinphos, Tetrachlovinphos, Tetraethyldithiopyrphos, Trichlorinate, Tukuthion, 2,4-D, Glyphosate, Pentachlorophenol.
Pentachlorophenol is an outdated wood preservative, which may also be formed as a by product of disinfection. Hexachlorobenzene is an outdated fungicide which may also be generated from several sources other than pesticide use. Due to the levels being below guideline levels, no correspondence is known to exist regarding these results.
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Vineyards in Australian here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Apple and Pear Orchard Pesticides
Pesticides Commonly Used in the Vegetable Industry in Victoria

Katamatite water supply channel. Atrazine, Endosulphan, Chlorpyrifos (Jan 06) and Heptachlor ( Oct 2000) have been detected in this channel system.
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Goulburn Valley Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
|
Town
|
Source of Water
|
Comments
|
| Alexandra | Goulburn River | |
| Avenel | Goulburn River piped from Seymour | |
| Barmah | Murray River | |
| Bonnie Doon | Lake Eildon | |
| Broadford | Sunday Creek* & Hazels & Harpers Creeks | |
| Buxton | Steavenson Creek | |
| Cobram | Murray River | |
| Colbinabbin | (western waranga channel), - Goulburn System | WWC treated with Weedmaster herbicide |
| Congupna | Goulburn System | |
| Corop | (u)(western waranga channel), - Goulburn System | |
| Dookie | (east goulburn main channel), - Goulburn System | |
| Eildon | Lake Eildon | |
| Euroa | Seven Creeks & Mt. Hut Creeks | |
| Girgarre | (GMW G7/12/9 channel), - Goulburn System | |
| Goulburn Weir(u) | Goulburn System | See Nagambie |
| Heathcote Junction | Sunday Creek* & Hazels & Harpers Creeks | |
| Katamatite | (GMW 7/3 channel), River Murray System (Boosey Creek?) | Pasture, crops mainly upstream |
| Katandra West | (GMW 2/24 channel), - Goulburn System | |
| Katunga | Ground Water | Depending on depth of ground water |
| Kilmore | Sunday Creek* & Hazels & Harpers Creeks | |
| Kirwans Bridge(u) | Goulburn System | See Nagambie |
| Kyabram | (GMW CG23/9 channel), - Goulburn System | |
| Longwood | Nine Mile Creek | |
| Mansfield | Delatite River (Ritchie Reservoir) | |
| Marysville | Steavenson Creek | |
| Merrigum | (CG23/9 channel via pipeline from kyabram), - Goulburn System | |
| Merrijig | Upper Delatite River | |
| Molesworth(u) | Goulburn System | |
| Mooroopna | Goulburn River pumped from Shepparton | |
| Murchison | Goulburn River | |
| Nagambie | Lake Nagambie | Lake Nagambie has been sprayed with Roundup Biactive to control aquatic weeds (Mexican Water Lily) since 1996. Roundup Biactive also used to kill water lily clumps in late 1996-March 1997. Initial levels of Glyphosate in 1996, unknown. 210 litres Glyhosate used in mid 1996. 577 litres of Glyphosate used late 1996-Mar 1997. 361 litres Nufarm Weedmaster 360 used Nov 97-Mar 98. Highest readings 38ppb detected. 490 litres (Roundup Biactive & Roundup 360) used 1999-2000. 886 litres (Roundup Biactive & Weedmaster) used 2000-01. 417 litres (Roundup Biactive, Weedmaster, Weedmaster 360) used 2001/2. 400.5 litres (Weedmaster 360, Glyphosate 360 & Weedmaster Duo) used early 2003. |
| Nathalia | Broken Creek | Broken Creek is sprayed with Roundup to control aquatic weeds |
| Numurkah | Broken Creek | Broken Creek is sprayed with Roundup to control aquatic weeds |
| Picola | (GMW 9/9/9 channel)- River Murray System | |
| Pyalong | Molisons Creek | |
| Rushworth | Outlet channel of Waranga Basin | |
| Sawmill Settlement | Upper Delatite River | |
| Seymour | Goulburn River | |
| Shepparton | Goulburn River | |
| Stanhope | (GMW CGI/12/9 channel),- Goulburn System | |
| Strathbogie(u) | Seven Creeks | |
| Strathmerton | Murray River | |
| Tallarook | Goulburn River piped from Seymour | |
| Tallygaroopna | Goulburn River pumped from Shepparton | |
| Tatura | (GMW CG 3/5A channel), - Goulburn System | Pasture and Crops mainly upstream |
| Thornton | Rubicon River | depending on location of offtake |
| Tongala | (GMW CG 16/28/9 + 28/9 channels), - Goulburn System | |
| Toolamba | Goulburn River pumped from Shepparton | |
| Violet Town | Seven Creeks & Mt. Hut Creeks | |
| Wandong | Sunday Creek & Hazels & Harpers Creeks | |
| Waterford Park | Sunday Creek & Hazels & Harpers Creeks | |
| Woods Point(u) | Brewery Creek | |
| Wunghnu | Broken Creek | |
| Yarrawonga | Murray River | |
| Yarroweyah | Murray River | |
| Yea | Yea River |

Time covered in FoI request: 25/6/05 - 20/8/07:
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline being constructed. This will substantially reduce risk of runoff into channels.
Current Pesticide Testing Regimes:
NATA accredited laboratory working on behalf of GWMWater, scan checks for traces of; Lindane, Aldrin, Dieldrin, Heptachlor Epoxide, 4-4-DDD, 4-4-DDE, 4,4-DDT, Hexachlorobenzene (HCB). Testing appears to be based on annual checks however it appears that some supplies are not tested annually and some more than annually. Due to the information sourced from the FoI further explanations are impossible.
No positive results detected.
GWMW also use glyphosate to control weeds in its channel system. "There are no tests for pesticides carried out on water flowing in the channels, since the vast majority of this water is destined for farm dams and non-potable use"
http://www.gwmwater.org.au/sm/weed_spraying.html "Weed Spraying The length of channel treated with chemical weedicides is growing as this form of treatment can defer the more expensive channel ditching in some instances. It is used extensively in the irrigation areas around Horsham where access along channels is a problem, and introduced weeds such as Elodea are rapidly spreading. Generally, GWMWater is responsible for channel waterway areas and the neighboring landholder manages weed control on channel banks and adjacent land."
Most GWMW is sourced from the Grampians and then transported via open channel system. At this stage Friends of the Earth has not assessed any of this infrastructure, much of which is being replaced by pipeline. It is anticipated that the pipeline will lessen significantly issues concerning possible channel pollution, however until an assessment can be made it is likely that open channels will be of some risk in terms of water quality, particularly as a large portion of this region is cropped.
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Vineyards in Australian here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Pesticides used in the Tree Plantation Industry in Victoria
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Grampians Wimmera Mallee Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
(u) means untreated water not recommended for drinking by GWMW
|
Town
|
Source of Supply
|
Comments
|
|
Antwerp(u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 1 Works Completed. Water Quality?
|
|
Apsley(u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast
|
|
|
Ararat
|
Langi Ghiran Reservoir, Picnic
Road Reservoir
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Berriwollock (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 5 Works occurrng 2008 Water Quality?
|
|
Beulah
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
Headworks Grampians – open channels through farmland
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 2 Works Completed Water Quality?
|
|
Birchip
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Brim
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 2 Works Completed
|
|
Buangor (u)
|
McLeod Creek Weir?
|
|
|
Charlton
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers Wimmera Mallee Pipeline Project Supply System 3 & 4 Works
Starts 2008
|
|
Chillingollah (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Chinkapook (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Clear Lake (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 6 Cosultation occurring 2008
|
|
Cowangie (u)
|
Ground Water Mallee Basin
|
|
|
Culgoa (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 5 Works occurrng 2008
|
|
Dimboola
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel fillers Wimmera Mallee Pipeline Project Supply System 1 Works Completed |
|
Donald
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 3 & 4 Works Starts 2008
|
|
Dooen (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 1 Works Completed
|
|
Edenhope
|
Lake Wallace + Ground Water emergency
supply
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Elmhurst (u)
|
Hickmans Creek?
|
|
|
Glenorchy (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
|
|
Goroke (u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast
|
|
|
Great Western
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers. Also Microfiltration
|
|
Halls Gap
|
Lake Bellfield, Dairy Creek Reservoir?
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Harrow (u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast
|
|
|
Haven
|
?
|
|
|
Hopetoun
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Horsham
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel fillers Wimmera Mallee Pipeline Project Supply System 6 Cosultation occurring 2008 |
|
Jerapit (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 1 Works Completed
|
|
Jung
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 2 Works Completed
|
|
Kaniva (u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast
|
|
|
Kiata (u)
|
Groundwater Kiata Bore
|
|
|
Lake Bolac
|
Mason Creek
|
|
|
Lake Fyans
|
Lake Fyans
|
Plantations established
within catchment 2007
|
|
Lalbert
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
|
|
Lascelles (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
|
|
Lillimur (u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast
|
|
|
Manangatang
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Marnoo (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 3 & 4 Works Starts 2008
|
|
Minyip
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
Headworks Grampians – open channels through farmland
|
|
|
Miram (u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast.
|
|
|
Moyston (u)
|
Stoney Creek (Hopkins River Basin),
Groundwater?
|
|
|
Murrayville
|
Ground Water Mallee Basin
|
|
|
Murtoa
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Nandaly (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Natimuk (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 6 Cosultation occurring 2008
|
|
Nhill (u)
|
Groundwater
|
|
|
Noradjuha (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
|
|
Nullawil
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
Headworks Grampians – open channels through farmland
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 5 Works occurring 2008
|
|
Ouyen
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River DAFF Treatment. Lime or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel fillers. Also Microfiltration |
|
Patchewollock (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Pimpinio (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 1 Works Completed
|
|
Pomonal
|
(same as Halls Gap), Lake Bellfield
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Quambatook
|
Goulburn Murray Water (Normanville
Supply System)
|
|
|
Rainbow
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers. Wimmera Mallee Pipeline Project Supply System 1
|
|
Rupunyap
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
Headworks Grampians – open channels through farmland
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 3 & 4 Works Starts 2008
|
|
Sea Lake
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Serviceton (Leeor) (u)
|
Ground Water Millicent Coast
|
|
|
Speed (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
St Arnaud
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System.
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers
|
|
Stawell
|
Fyans Creek, Lake Fyans
|
Plantations established within catchment 2007 DAFF Treatment. Lime or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel fillers |
|
Streatham (u)
|
Ground Water
|
|
|
Tarranyurk (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline Project
Supply System 1 Works Completed
|
|
Tempy (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Ultima
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Underbool (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Waitchie (u)
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Walpeup
|
Northern Mallee Pipeline or Normanville
Pipeline
|
Source: Murray River
|
|
Warracknabeal
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
DAFF Treatment. Lime
or caustic soda may be added. Alum & Polyelectroytes added. Sand/carbon/gravel
fillers Wimmera Mallee Pipeline Project Supply System 2 Works Completed
|
|
Watchem
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
|
|
Westmere (u)
|
Ground Water
|
|
|
Wickliffe (u)
|
||
|
Willaura
|
Mason Creek
|
|
|
Woomelang
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
|
|
Wycheproof
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 3 & 4 Works Starts 2008
|
|
Yaapeet (u)
|
Wimmera Mallee Channel System
|
Wimmera Mallee Pipeline
Project Supply System 1 Works Completed
|

August 26, 2008: Brumby and Ministers Come Under Fire at Water Protests
Note: No testing for Atrazine, which Goulburn Murray Water detected above Kerang supply (dec 04, sep 05, nov 05, jan06-apr06). Endosulfan detected GMW sep 05, bifenthrin, esfenvalerate & taufluvalinate oct 05)
Time covered in FoI request: 1995 - Nov 06:
Monitoring taken at 9 sites. Samples of raw water for a suite of organochlorine pesticides analyses have been taken on a quarterly basis since 1995. All results of this testing has been reported as less than the detection limits. Since 2005-6, additional testing has been carried out an annual basis to test for additional pestcides, ones that are commonly used in the LMW water supply catchment. These include Atrazine, Chlorpyrifos, Chlorothalonil, Methomyl, Molinate, Maldison & Diuron. These are sampled in place of one of the quarterly OCP samplings. The first sampling took place in May 2006, the second in November 2006 and the third is scheduled for February 2008. All results from the first two samplings were reported as less than the detection limit of 0.03µg/L, with the exception of atrazine in the May 2006 sampling. In May 2006, results for Red Cliffs, Mildura Piangil were reported as 0.03µg/L.
Pesticides used in Cropping in Victoria here
Pesticides used in Vineyards in Australian here
Pesticides used in Grazing Industry in Victoria
Apple and Pear Orchard Pesticides
Pesticides Commonly Used in the Vegetable Industry in Victoria
Table of places supplied with drinking water from Lower Murray Water. Red indicates risk, Orange indicates lower risk, Green indicates very low risk.
|
Towns
|
Source of Water
|
Comments
|
|
Swan Hill, Lake Boga, Nyah, Nyah
West, Woorinen South
|
Murray River
|
|
|
Robinvale
|
Murray River
|
|
|
Red Cliffs
|
Murray River
|
|
|
Piangil
|
Murray River
|
|
|
Mildura, Mildura West, Irymple,
Merbein, Nichols Point, Cabarita, Kings Billabong, Mildura South
|
Murray River
|
|
|
Kerang
|
Murray River, Loddon River, 14/2
Irrigation Channel
|
|
|
Koondrook
|
Murray River
|
|
|
Murrabit
|
Murray River
|

June 25 2009: Tarrago Reservoir Reconnected
August 26, 2008: Brumby and Ministers Come Under Fire at Water Protests
July 15 2008: Chemicals net cast wider (Melbourne Water to start testing for more pesticides).
Complacency in Action?
Time covered in FoI request: 4/2/97 - 25/1/08:
Melbourne Water supply treated water to Yarra Valley Water, South East Water and City West Water (soon also to Westernport Water). Melbourne Water also do testing.
Most of the catchments that Melbourne Water sources its water from are 'closed/protected' catchments. However Sugarloaf Reservoir, commissioned in November 1980, sources its water from the Yarra River, meaning that it is exposed to more contaminants than other reservoirs in the Melbourne Water Network.
Generally speaking almost all water supplied to South East Water does not come from Sugarloaf Reservoir and a large percentage supplied to Yarra Valley Water also does not come Sugarloaf. Water quality from closed catchment sources is likely to be good. For these reasons detailed analysis of South East Water, Yarra Valley Water and City West Water was not carried out, as they rely on Melbourne Water for all testing. Probably less than 15% of Melbourne Water is supplied from Sugarloaf Reservoir.
Positive Pesticide Results:
Johns Hill Plant 7/2/00 (Kallista) for; Aldrin 0.00002 MG/L (100% over guideline value), Lindane 0.00002 (40% under guideline value), Heptachlor 0.000013 (under guideline value).
Johns Hill Plant was supplied via closed pipeline from Silvan Reservoir, which raises the question was the source of the organochlorines Silvan and if so why were the pesticides detected at Johns Hill and not at Silvan?
Heptachlor and Heptachlor Epoxide were also found in sediment, downstream of Reefton in 1996 in the UWRAA study (22).
Pesticide Monitoring post mid 2008:
In mid 2008 Melbourne Water expanded its testing in reservoirs and drinking supply. The additional compounds now tested for are; Hexazinone, MCPA, Triclopyr, Asulam, Glyphosate, Captan, Carbaryl, Chlorpyrifos, Esfenvalerate, Maldison, Mancozeb, Parathion Methyl, Propargite, Simazine, Picloram, Cyprodinil, Metham, Methyl Bromide, Pyrimethanil, 1,3 dichloropropene, Iprodione, Methomyl, Bromoxynil, Metiram, Chlorothanlonil, Chloropicrin. This is in addition to the pesticides already tested for Aldrin, Dieldrin, Chlordane, DDT, Heptachlor, Heptachlor epoxide, Lindane, 2,4-D and Atrazine.
A Freedom of Information Request dated 23 June 2009, showed that the improved testing regime detected no herbicides between June 2008-May 2009. Testing appears to be conducted roughly every two weeks at a number of locations (only at Yering Gorge on the Yarra).
In early 2008 Friends of the Earth identified several pesticides of high concern in the Yarra Catchment. Melbourne Water's new testing regimes will only test for four of these substances. The following pesticides of concern will not be tested for; Abamectin, Azinphos Methyl, Dimethoate, Diquat, Endosulfan, Paraquat, Pirimicarb and Thiram.
Pesticide Monitoring 1996-mid 2008:
Two pesticide testings per year for; (Aldrin, Chlordane, Lindane, DDT, Dieldrin, Heptachlor, Heptachlor Epoxide, 2,4-D) + Atrazine since 1/8/05. Most tests carried out at; Cardinia O/L Main, Cresswell Res - Tap on O/L, Dromana 900mm Detention Point, Frankston Detention Pt, Johns Hill Tank Outlet Main, Mornington Detention Point, Silvan Olinda Main Det. Pt, Yan Yean T.P. Detention Point, Yarra Glen Res - Tap on Tank, Winneke Preston Main Research. Pentachlorophenol also tested for?
What this means is that Melbourne Water were only testing for two currently used pesticides.
Melbourne Water have recently had a risk analysis done and a number of agricultural chemicals were identified that Melbourne Water will be doing further research on. They will be focussing on the ten most commonly used pesticides in the catchment. Their study will start in July 2008 (One should wonder why it has taken Melbourne Water 27 years to conduct such a study - Sugarloaf was completed in 1981 and almost no research has been conducted for two decades!)
Sugarloaf Reservoir provides drinking water to almost 700,000 people in the Melbourne suburbs of; Alphington, Arthurs Creek, Balwyn, Balwyn East, Balwyn North, Banyule, Box Hill North, Briar Hill, Brunswick, Brunswick East, Brunswick West, Bulleen, Bundoora, Burwood, Camberwell, Canterbury, Coburg, Croxton, Deepdene, Diamond Creek, Doncaster, Doreen, Eaglemont, Eltham, Epping, Fairfield, Glen Iris, Greensborough, Greythorn, Hawthorn, Hawthorn East, Heidelberg, Heidelberg Heights, Heidelberg West, Hurstbridge, Ivanhoe, Kangaroo Ground, Keon Park, Kew, Kingsbury, Lalor, Lower Plenty, Maclead, Malvern, Mernda, Mill Park, Mont Albert, Montmorency, Northcote, Northland Centre, Nutfield, Pascoe Vale, Plenty, Preston, Research, Reservoir, Rosanna, Smiths Gully, South Morang, Templestowe Lower, Thomastown, Thornbury, View Bank, Watsonia, Wattle Glen, Whittlesea, Yallambie, Yarrambat.
Sugarloaf Reservoir also supplies almost 500,000 customers of City West Water in the following regions; Werribee, Little River, Altona, Werribee South, Footscray, Deer Park, East Keilor, Strathmore, Moonee Ponds, Parkville.
Sugarloaf Reservoir sometimes supplies South East Water Customers, particularly in drier times. Suburbs include; Albert Park, Balaclava, Gardenvale, Garden City, Fishermens Bend, Elwood, Elsternwick, Melbourne, Middle Park, Prahan, Ripponlea, South Melbourne, South Yarra, Southbank, St/Kilda/West, St.Kilda/East, Windsor.
Pesticide Potential Maps of the catchment upstream of Sugarloaf Reservoir were produced by Friends of the Earth in March 2008. They reveal widespread agricultural land use in the land above the offtake to the reservoir. The Yarra River Catchment upstream of Sugarloaf Reservoir could be one of the most intensively farmed and sprayed regions of any water supply located in Victoria. The catchment (outside of closed catchments) provides more than 1.2 million people with drinking water.
Copies of the maps can be found here and here. Friends of the Earth also claim that the following pesticides should be tested for by Melbourne Water but aren't;
|
Land Use (excluding grazing, urban and forestry)above
Offtake to Sugarloaf
|
ha
|
Number of Agrochemicals Registered in Victoria by
Crop Type
|
|
Vineyards
|
3904.3
|
~110+
|
|
Orchards (Apples, Citrus etc)
|
1549.2
|
~65-110
|
|
Cut Flowers/Nurseries etc
|
1225.9
|
?
|
|
Potatoes
|
989.22
|
~70+
|
|
Berries (Strawberries, Rasberries, etc)
|
936.52
|
25+
|
|
Vegetables
|
490.37
|
15-75
|
|
Tree Plantations
|
117.47
|
~35
|
|
Olives
|
32.94
|
~10
|
|
Total
|
9244.92
|
*Friends of the Earth Melbourne study 2008.
Main Pesticides of concern to health of Melbournians would likely be: Parathion Methyl, Paraquat, Diquat, Simazine, Chlorpyrifos, Carbaryl, Methomyl.
Other pesticides of concern to the health of both people and the Yarra River and tributaries would probably be; Mancozeb, Maldison, Thiram, Metiram, Pirimicarb, Triclopyr, Ipriodione, Dimethoate, Captan, Endosulfan, Abamectin, Propargite, Azinphos Methyl & Esfenvalerate. Information in table below is sourced from the Pesticide Action Network
|
Pesticide Name
|
Type
|
|
PAN BAD ACTOR
|
ACUTE TOXICITY
|
CARCINOGEN
|
CHOLINESTERASE INHIBITOR
|
GROUND WATER CONTAMINANT
|
DEVELOPMENTAL REPRODUCTIVE TOXIN
|
ENDOCRINE DISRUPTOR |
|
Abamectin
|
Botanical
|
I
|
YES
|
YES
|
NOT LIKELY
|
NO
|
?
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Azinphos Methyl
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
YES
|
YES
|
NOT LIKELY
|
YES
|
POTENTIAL
|
?
|
?
|
|
Captan
|
Thiophthalimide
|
F
|
YES
|
YES
|
YES
|
NO
|
?
|
?
|
?
|
|
Carbaryl
|
Methyl Carbamate
|
I
|
YES
|
MOD
|
YES
|
YES
|
POTENTIAL
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Chlorpyrifos
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
YES
|
MOD
|
NOT LIKELY
|
YES
|
?
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Dimethoate
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
YES
|
YES
|
POSSIBLE
|
YES
|
POTENTIAL
|
YES
|
?
|
|
Diquat
|
Bipyridylium
|
H
|
NOT LISTED
|
MODERATE
|
NOT LIKELY
|
NO
|
POTENTIAL
|
?
|
?
|
|
Endosulfan
|
Organochlorine
|
I
|
YES
|
YES
|
NOT LIKELY
|
NO
|
?
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Esfenvalerate
|
Pyrethroid
|
I
|
NOT LISTED
|
MODERATE
|
NOT LIKELY
|
NO
|
?
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Maldison
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
YES
|
MODERATE
|
POSSIBLE
|
YES
|
POTENTIAL
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Mancozeb
|
Dithiocarbamate Inorganic Zinc
|
F
|
YES
|
NOT ACUTELY
|
CARCINOGEN
|
NO
|
?
|
YES
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Methomyl
|
Methyl Carbamate
|
I
|
YES
|
YES
|
NOT LIKELY
|
YES
|
POTENTIAL
|
?
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Metiram
|
Dithiocarbamate Inorganic Zinc
|
F
|
YES
|
NOT ACUTELY
|
YES
|
NO
|
POTENTIAL
|
YES
|
SUSPECTED
|
|
Paraquat
|
Bipyridylium
|
H
|
YES
|
YES
|
NOT LIKELY
|
NO
|
POTENTIAL
|
?
|
?
|
|
Parathion Methyl
|
Organophosphorus
|
I
|
YES
|
YES
|
UNCLASSIFIABLE
|
YES
|
POTENTIAL
|